Chapter Text
JUNE 5th
I hate my mom’s new boyfriend.
For the past three months she’d been telling me about this new guy who’s “The One” as if “The One” hasn’t been like four other guys in the past two years.
And as much as I’d love for my mom to find someone to spend the rest of her life with, I don’t believe she’d ever find Mr. Perfect at this rate. Unless she spent more than a few months with them at a time before dragging me home from college for a weekend to meet them, I really don’t see it happening.
It just sucks. Because every time she does this, every time I return home, I see the glimmering hope in her eyes and the diminishing spark in his, and I know. I know it won’t last, and her heart will be utterly broken within the span of a few months.
I always thought maybe she just had terrible taste in men.
But this time around, when I begrudgingly walk through the door of my childhood home for the summer and see my mother clinging to a man who returns that glimmer in her eyes, I know she’s picked a good one.
And I hate him.
His name is Spencer Reid, and he’s a retired FBI agent who teaches full time at local colleges now.
He greets me with a bona fide, radiant smile, unlike all the others before, and it sets my insides on fire. And when we sit down for dinner, he’s polite (but not in a fake way,) and he seems genuinely curious about my studies and my personality and my relationship with my mother. And when dinner is finished he offers to clean up while Mom and I settle in the living room.
I see the way he looks at me as I leave, a gentle, closed-mouth smile and eyes that linger a little too long on my exposed legs before averting, a glint of shame pooling within them, and it only spreads that fire in my belly.
Maybe I’d been imagining the whole thing, because deep down I wanted him to look at me the way he had… But it’s hard to tell when my brain is mostly setting off sirens, blaring “THIS IS WRONG! THIS IS WRONG!” on a loop with blinding lights.
And they’re even louder when my mom wraps her arm around me and lays her head atop mine. “Well, what do you think? He’s great, huh?”
She’s so lovesick, it hurts. It hurts even worse knowing that all I can think about is his big hands wrapped around my throat while he fucks me into the squeaky twin-sized mattress in my bedroom upstairs.
But I can’t tell her that, obviously.
And so I decidedly hate him. And I have no choice but lie to her face, embracing her joy and hoping that I’ll be able to survive this summer.
“Yeah, Mom. He’s really great.”
JUNE 19th
It’s been two weeks and I can barely stand to be in the same house anymore.
I try to keep myself busy by going outside, to the beach or for long walks in the park; but it’s too hot for my liking, and our town is so small that unless I want to spend my time in the grocery store or one of the three bars on Main Street…
I’m stuck either outside where it’s hot and uncomfortable, or in the house where it’s also hot and uncomfortable.
We have air conditioning, of course, but that’s not the problem.
It’s Spencer.
I thought by now my little crush on him would have gone, but the longer he hangs around the house, the stronger my feelings for him grow. They’re not romantic—nor do I think they ever could be given the fact that if anything serious really were to ever happen between us, my mom would disown me for the rest of my life and murder Spencer with her bare hands—but that doesn’t make it any easier on me.
Every day he just exists, right in front of me with that tug-able mop of hair, those warm honey eyes, and his hands that never stop moving. I swear, it’s like every time he breathes, his hands are breathing too, challenging me to try and stop them.
But I refuse to touch him. Because I know the moment I do, all will be lost. I won’t be able to control myself anymore. And if I don’t drop to my knees and try sucking his dick at the dinner table, I’m sure I’ll blurt out how I can’t handle it anymore and that I need him, and either way I’d be royally fucked.
Right now he’s in the dining room, teaching my mom how to do a disappearing card trick. She thinks it’s utterly charming that he can do it at all, but mostly that he’s patient and willing enough to teach her. And normally I’d agree, but I can barely look at them without wanting to waltz over, grab his wrist, and suck his fingers into my mouth.
It’s truly pathetic.
So I try to focus on the television just a few feet away. It’s one of those rare instances where I wish our house was bigger, because while I don’t mind having less wall-space between rooms, I do mind not being able to watch TV without the kitchen table in my periphery at a time like this. And I think about going up to my bedroom instead for a moment, but I’d have to go past the kitchen, and I just know Mom is going to ask if I’d want Spencer to teach me his magic trick.
And I most definitely do not want that.
In another life, maybe, where he isn’t a hot professor and rather an average-looking dude who’s way too into fantasy football… But not in this lifetime.
So there I sit, concentrating so hard on Family Feud that my face hurts.
When I hear a flutter of cards and joyous giggling from the other room, it’s more than my face that hurts.
It’s also my chest, churning and tensing at the hands of the green devil.
Fuck!
I barely even know this man… I haven’t really talked to him because I’m afraid that if I try to hold a conversation I’ll snap. He’s literally just some hot older guy who’s dating my mom, and still, my whole body twists and aches with envy when they do anything together, and it fucking sucks. Not only because of the jealousy, but it’s also the fact that my mom deserves to be happy.
This time it’s different. This time, she’s really found someone who returns her every loving gaze, who makes her laugh, who’s kind and genuine and not a total douche. She’s happier than I’ve seen her in years.
And the one time she finally finds “The One”, every waking second of my life is spent longing for him fuck me.
But it’s only been two weeks.
And it’s also been nearly two years since I got laid, so maybe that’s just my issue…
I figure it can’t hurt, so in a spur of the moment decision, I turn the TV off and sprint towards the stairs, right past Mom and Spencer before they can ask questions.
———
I hardly even register the dimness of the light inside the house by the time I glide up the steps, fumbling with the key and trying to make my entrance as quiet as possible. Though, because I’m so used to the dark by this point, the light—no matter how dim—nearly blinds me. The door shuts louder than I’d have liked, and I cringe inwardly, pausing as if that will keep anyone from seeing or hearing me. Not like it’ll matter, considering Mom and Spencer are the only ones that are staying here and they’d also been the only ones aware of my plans for the evening.
Well, somewhat, anyway. I told them an old friend invited me out and I probably wouldn’t be home until late.
Regardless, that instinct of trying not to get caught coming in late at night is stronger than common sense. Throw a little cheap beer and some shots into the mix, and it almost feels like I’m a teenager again.
The only thing different now is that I have a pool of some stranger’s cum soaking my underwear and a man in front of me who stands like an angel. An exhausted, almost scruffy-looking angel more like, but my point still stands.
“You’re up late,” Spencer observes. It’s a simple enough statement— not really judge-y, but I can tell that regardless of his knowledge of my coming home late, he seems shocked to see me coming through the front door right now.
And it’s hard to look away from him. Just like it has been for the past two weeks. Still, I try, just barely avoiding his eyes as I cross my arms and fight the urge to clench my legs together. “I’m a whore. What’s your excuse?”
Maybe not the best thing to say. But like I said, common sense? Gone.
“O—oh… Umm…” Spencer stumbles through his words, obviously stunned by my response, and the look in his eyes kind of makes me want to curl up in a ball and die from embarrassment. Still, I stand my ground and wait for him to continue.
He settles on a short, “I can’t sleep,” and then there’s nothing else.
“Ah,” I express. One syllable. I don’t draw it out, I don’t exaggerate it… This is the first real conversation I’ve had alone with him, and I’ve made it extremely awkward, so I sigh and take a few steps forward, trying to walk past him. “Okay. Goodnight.”
I only make it a few steps before he stops me, his hand reaching out to tap my shoulder. “Wait—”
The touch makes me jump, and he pulls it away immediately as I turn to face him. My heart is racing at the speed of light, my panties are soaked through, and if I’m not careful that whole ‘no common sense’ thing is going to bite me so hard in the ass I won’t have one left.
“Can I talk to you?” His voice is barely audible, and the gentle rasp it has to it seems to make me even more wet.
I nod, not trusting myself to speak.
“Look, I um… Your mom has been totally transparent with me about her relationships, so I know that she’s been through a lot of them in a short amount of time… And I know that must be a little difficult for you. Especially now that I’m here… And you’ve been… distant. And I know that I don’t know you that well, so forgive me if I’m assuming anything, but I just want you to know that I don’t have any intention of making things difficult for you and your mother.”
Too late, pal, I think bitterly, the gentle authority in his tone setting my insides alight. I’m positive that voice could get me to do so many things…
That’s the alcohol and sex talking, Y/N, just shake it and move on…
He starts again, but I cut him off with a short wave of my hand. “Look, I… I appreciate what you’re trying to do, but I had a really long night, and I’m exhausted. I just wanna shower and go to bed.”
I expect more resistance, but Spencer only nods. I still can’t bring myself to look him in the eye, though this time I catch his hands clenching at the bottom hem of his shirt. “I understand. Sleep well.”
Without another word I turn on my heel and walk a little faster towards the stairs, and I’m about to take my first step when I realize he’s followed me. His voice calls out my name softly from a few feet behind, and it stops me in my tracks regardless of my desire to get out of there as fast as I can. And then I turn around and finally look directly at his face.
Big mistake.
His eyes are on my legs again, trailing slowly upwards until he reaches my face. The light over here is dimmer, barely noticeable at all, though I swear I can see red forming on his cheeks.
“I like your dress,” he says softly. It’s almost meek, like he’d been afraid to say it but took a chance anyway.
It’s such a random, small compliment, but with the alcohol and endorphins flowing through my body after the night I’d just had, it nearly makes me quiver.
It also makes me incredibly stupid.
An amused, almost sensual grin forms on my face as I make eye contact with him, and I feel myself throb at the way I can just barely see his throat move. He looks like a deer in headlights, afraid to make one sudden move.
“Turning to flattery to try and win me over, are we?” I say slowly.
I almost think he’ll stumble over his words once more, but again he surprises me with a full answer. It’s only three words but it’s clear, and his voice is deep, and I want to fucking jump his bones right then and there.
“Is it working?”
This has to be the alcohol making me imagine things… I swear I didn’t even drink that much tonight, but it has to be an obvious lapse in judgement. The drinking mixed with the sex mixed with the dirty thoughts I’ve been having about this man lately have to be what’s making this feel real. It’s all culminating into this one big fantasy (or delusion, more like), and all I need is to shower and sleep it off.
That has to be it.
So because there’s no other reasonable explanation that my brain can conjure up, I take a chance and throw Spencer a wink before turning and sprinting up the stairs.
And it’s that same seemingly undeniable reasoning for this illusion that doesn’t keep my hands from wandering in the shower. Even though those warning sirens in my brain keep blaring, telling me that the common sense is still there for me to utilize, they’re drowned out by my thrumming heartbeat and the repetition of Spencer’s soothing, authoritative voice, guiding my movements.
Keep rubbing your clit for me, baby… Just like that, nice and slow…
Warm water cascades down the front of my body as I lean back into the wall of the shower, but that’s not why I’m so warm. This heat radiates through my insides, spreading like wildfire and bringing out small whimpers and mewls that I know I’ll have to contain in fear of waking my mom from her bedroom right next door.
But then the thought of her hearing me next door as I cry out her boyfriend’s name only excites me more. I keep it quiet still, but just knowing that someone else is in the house while I’m having these thoughts right now (one of them being the object of said thoughts) is what finally brings me over the edge.
I finish my shower on weak legs, definitely overstimulated now, but also feeling even more tired. I know that the moment I lay down on my bed, I’ll be pulled into the sweet, soft surrender of a deep sleep.
Nothing else has ever sounded so pleasant.
———
When I woke up that morning after, I was feeling surprisingly calm. Realistically I knew that my whole ’this has to be an illusion’ montage had been less truth and more inebriated babble, and the longer I sat on it the more I thought it’d all turned out for the better.
Turns out, tipsily masturbating in the shower to thoughts of your mom’s hot new boyfriend was a surefire way to get it out of your system, right?
Wrong.
It really had been okay at first. I thought about Spencer almost immediately, and yeah, he was still hot as fuck—But there wasn’t this overwhelming desire within me to jump his bones when I saw him that morning, his hair messy and his hands clutching a cup of coffee while Mom made breakfast behind him.
But that good feeling I had about all of this? It lasts only about a split second.
Because the moment he looks up and sees me, the mug falls out of his hand and shatters to pieces. His eyes stay glued to me, even as my mother darts over to pick up the pieces of the ceramic that are scattered about the table and the floor. And when she turns back to grab a paper towel, he still stares at me, once again at my legs.
It takes me all of four seconds afterwards to remember that not only did I talk to him briefly last night, but I also flirted with him after he complimented me.
That whole part seemed to have slipped my mind when waking up, and now that his gaze is bringing me back to that moment, that ’this has to be an illusion’ montage is starting to become larger than I’d remembered.
It isn’t until he finally snaps out of it and starts to help my mom clean up the mess that I snap out of it, too, going back upstairs to clear my head and cool the heat radiating over my skin.
———
There’s a knock at my bedroom door about an hour later, and it sounds different than my mom’s usually quick two-knock succession. That means it’s someone else, and unsurprisingly, my stomach tightens at the thought of seeing him again.
“Yeah?” I call out, turning in my desk chair and meeting Spencer’s figure in the doorway. He’s changed, a rather nice pair of slacks and a white button-up shirt clinging to his limbs.
“Can I come in?”
“Mhm,” I say. I still don’t know if I entirely trust myself to say anything more than a few words to him, and as he enters the room and sits on the foot of my bed, I wonder if he can tell.
He tries, really tries, to look me in the eye, but I know that it’s hard. I’ve been in the same spot. And then he takes a deep breath before folding his hands in his lap.
“Y/N, I want to apologize… When we… talked last night… It was kind of weird, and then this morning wasn’t really any better…” He can barely get out the words 'talk’ and 'last night’… And then he avoids my gaze altogether, staring at the floor and trailing off, trying to put his thoughts together it seems.
And that’s when it starts to click into place.
There’s one thing that both last night and this morning have in common, and I’ve noticed it almost every time I’ve caught him staring at me. At my legs. It’s happened almost daily since I’ve met him. And then, the night I come home clearly having just been fucked, waltzing past him, entertaining his fascination with my legs and then masturbating to thoughts of him in the shower, he finally starts dropping mugs.
He must also really feel something here. Something similar to my own feelings. And really, that should be a red flag, because he’s my mom’s boyfriend, and it’s a goddamned fucking mess…
But fuck, it excites me.
I’m still wearing my pajama shorts, silky and lavender in color, and I use them to my advantage, slowly crossing one leg over the other and just barely gaining Spencer’s attention back.
“Yeah, what was that, anyway?” I ask him, amusement dripping off my tongue.
I can tell from his reaction that he wasn’t expecting me to ask. A few times he opens his mouth to speak and then closes it , stumbling before panicking. He’s been pretty good so far at coming up with answers and explanations, so the fact that this time I finally seemed to have broken him down makes it all the more clear.
He must have heard me in the shower.
Right?
I’m almost completely positive that’s what this is about. And there’s one way for me to get the confirmation I’m looking for.
“So you heard me, huh?”
I try to keep my voice as plain as I can as not to give away my motives, and with my luck Spencer is so flustered that he probably wouldn’t have even noticed it at all. He looks up at me, his eyes desperately trying to find something he can use to make up a lie, but in the end there’s no use.
I’ve caught him. And he knows it.
“Yes,” he whispers. He looks exhausted, guilty, and also a little like he wants to cross the barrier and kiss me.
Okay, maybe that part’s just in my head. I really can’t tell. But I do know that hearing me call his name out in the shower last night is what brought him to this point of severe distress. As much as that excites me, though, it also embarrasses me a little. Maybe if it hadn’t happened we could have avoided further destruction.
It must read on my face, because Spencer perks a little. “Oh! Y/N, I’m not… I’m not mad or anything. I really didn’t mean to overhear and invade your privacy… Really, I-I’m sorry.”
The fact that he’s apologizing to me right now, rather than acting all grossed out that I even did it in the first place, tells me he either feels guilty for not being able to help himself from hearing me, or he’s just a good guy who loves my mom and doesn’t want to ruin it because of a little mishap.
Either way, it’s frustrating, because I don’t know what to do.
Well, I know what I want to do, but I don’t know if I should hint at it.
But then he does something. It’s small, and no one would have noticed, but I’ve been fascinated with his hands since the moment I met him, so my eyes are instantly drawn there.
They’re clenched so hard, his knuckles are nearly white.
He’s nervous.
To ease his mind a bit, I hold off on poking the bear harder (though it’s really tempting to see what will happen if I don’t) and nod, trying to make myself look as apologetic and small as possible.
“It’s okay… I… I won’t make it awkward if you won’t?”
His shoulders slump, and his body seems to relax. “Y–yeah. Yeah, deal.”
He gets up off the bed and blurts one final apology before heading for the door, but that part of me that wants to poke the bear further makes me stand up and follow him.
“Spencer?” I call out.
He freezes and turns to face me, and I don’t think he quite expected me to be as close as I am. I have to tilt my head up to look at him, and the angle gives me an added layer of this innocence I’m trying to achieve.
“I’m sorry, too…”
No the fuck I’m not.
Whether he can sense my lie or not, he doesn’t show it. But I think he at least knows that I’m pitching my voice a little higher on purpose, and if that doesn’t give it away, the way I’m staring at him sure should.
Still, he only nods and retreats.
All there’s left to do is see what happens.
JUNE 25th
For someone who agreed not to make things awkward, Spencer sure can’t keep his eyes off of me.
To be fair, I have tried to keep things fairly normal. I only really interacted with him if I had to, I kept my distance, and I saved my skimpier clothing for the strangers I was regularly going out to see almost every weekend.
My lustful feelings for him aren’t as strong now that I’ve been getting some on a semi-regular basis and keeping myself occupied. I’ve been doing my part.
But I still can’t shake him entirely.
Whenever he spends the night (which is surprisingly most nights), the occasional wet dream about him gets me frustrated when I know he’s just down the hall and sleeping soundly next to my mom. On those days I try to cut as much interaction with him as I can, though it doesn’t keep me from seeing the occasional stare he throws my way.
I wish I could say that I hate it.
But I don’t, and it increasingly gets worse. It’s only been a week, so there’s still time, but honestly, I don’t think there’s any shaking him.
Today especially is one of those days where it’s hard not to give into the incessant need to tease him and coax some stronger reaction out of him.
I talked to Mom earlier this morning about getting some new clothes, and she had this brilliant idea to have Spencer take me. “It would be a good chance for you two to bond a little, don’t you think?” she insisted, nudging him in the side and silently pleading with her eyes for him to agree.
I could tell from the look on his face that he really wasn’t ready to be alone with me again, but that only excited me.
“Yeah, I think that’s a great idea,” I piped up, positively beaming.
Mom was so excited for us to 'bond’ and also that I was gladly inclined to go through with it that Spencer couldn’t have said no to her even if he wanted to.
And I was pretty sure he didn’t want to.
Yet here we are, sitting in the car, the air conditioning so strong it’s blowing some of my hair into my eyes. I think it had been his way of punishing me for choosing today to wear a short skirt, something I usually refrain from nowadays unless I’m going out, and it makes me smile. I can’t help it.
I also can’t help the way my fingers play with my skirt, dying to tease him some more. I just want to see, to know for sure that I’m driving him mad.
“No offense, but you seem weird today… Is there something wrong?” I ask him, lifting my skirt just a smidge. The air from the car blows the fabric in waves.
“You’re acting this way on purpose.”
Well, I hadn’t been expecting that answer… All this time he’d hardly been confrontative, and now he’s full-on calling me out. It’s plain to see that he’s finally snapped, and I would have felt sorry about it if I didn’t find it extremely sexy.
“What do you mean?”
“Y/N…”
My name on his lips is a warning. He’s clearly annoyed, exasperated, and I’m loving every second. “Don’t act oblivious. I’m not stupid, and neither are you. I don’t want to make you hate me or anything, but you have to know where I’m coming from. I was willing to let the shower thing slide… And you said you were too, for that matter, so I don’t know what’s changed, but it has to stop now. Understood?”
Oh, all I want is to argue with him. I want to point out that none of this is really my fault because he’s the one who hasn’t been able to stop staring at me all summer so far. I want to tell him that if he wants this to stop he has to make it stop.
But that isn’t going to give me any of the answers I’m looking for or further proof of my theory that he wants me just as badly as I want him. And I am not going to fuck this whole situation up by making a poorly-timed move on him.
I have to know for sure.
So, I fold my hands neatly in my lap, sigh, and look dead ahead. “Right… We said no awkwardness. I’m sorry.”
Spencer seems to accept my apology and continues down the road.
When we make it to the mall I think he’s calmed down. At least, he seems a little more comfortable around me, and honestly I’m okay with it. As much as his spiel in the car turned me on, it also exhausted me to the point of silence.
Even as we walk around each store in the mall, I just lead and he follows, not saying a word when I pick out a top or a pair of pants or whatever else I need. And when it comes time to pay, he takes the basket from me and pays for it with no question.
Near five bags of clothes later, I figure I could get used to this new dynamic.
But then we pass a lingerie store, and I remember that the main thing I’d needed was new underwear. I start to turn into the store, but stop suddenly, pausing awkwardly and deciding to go straight ahead instead.
“You don’t want to go in?” Spencer asks.
I shake my head. “No, it’s fine. I can just pick some up later, it’s not a big deal.”
He sighs then, nodding his head towards the sign. “If you need to go in, you can… I’ll just wait out here if you’re uncomfortable.”
I really want to call him out, ask him if he’s the one who should be worried about being uncomfortable. But so far this afternoon has been pretty decent, and I really don’t want to make things any weirder than they have to be.
Besides… If my theory is right…
“Sure. Thanks. Uh, how am I gonna pay, though?”
“O—Oh… I’ll uh… I’ll just watch the counter and come in when you need me.”
“Orrrr, you could just give it to me?”
This time I get a laugh out of him. “Not a chance. Go in, I’ll wait.”
I smile at him and hand him the bags to hold onto while I leave, and it fills me with absolute amusement that he’d just given me one more ounce of proof that I’m right.
He’s gonna have to come inside and pay for what I bought. He could have just given me the card, and maybe he truly doesn’t trust me with it (which I don’t know why he wouldn’t honestly), but he chose to come inside all the same.
I browse happily then, going through the displays and picking out things I need, but also things I know Spencer will like.
Specifically, I stumble on a pair of lavender panties, embroidered with flowery trim up top. The pattern from the outside is lace, but there’s a thin layer of cotton underneath designed to be more comfortable to wear.
I’ve noticed that he can never seem to look away when I’m wearing anything, really, but it’s more intense when I wear one of two things. Florals, and any type of purple. And these fit both of those bills perfectly.
Now there’s just one more bill to take care of.
I stride over to the counter and turn around, finding that Spencer’s caught my eye immediately. Either he truly had been paying attention to the counter the whole time, or he’d been watching through the glass, following me with his gaze to the best of his abilities. Either way, he blinks a few times and looks like he’s gathering the courage to go in before actually taking any steps.
I laugh to myself, eager to gauge his reaction to this next step.
Surprisingly, he holds up well. The air between me, him, and the cashier is obviously awkward, but he doesn’t say anything and barely looks at what she rings up. (I say barely because he tries extremely hard not to look at the purple pair I picked out, inadvertently adding another checkmark to my list of proof.) She tells him the total, he hands her the card, and within a minute, everything is in our possession and we’re leaving the mall entirely.
I don’t think there are any more steps to my plan today once we get in the car and I tell him thank you. (To which he responds a short and simple, Sure thing, and turns the radio on.)
But then there’s a note taped to the front door, and it instantly gives me another one.
My Sweethearts,
I got called in on a work emergency and won’t be back until 7. I would have called but I figured you were having a nice time and didn’t want to interrupt! I’ll bring home dinner, and then maybe you can tell me about how your day went. Can’t wait to hear it!
XOXO,
Eve/Mom
I check my phone, seeing that it’s almost 3.
Perfect.
But I don’t want to give myself away too quickly, so I thank Spencer again for taking me out and tell him that I’m going upstairs to make sure everything fits right. He nods and lets me go, though not without lingering eyes. I can feel it.
The smile never leaves my face as I try all my clothes on. Once each article has been fitted, I throw it in a laundry basket and move to the next, until I get to the last piece.
The lavender panties.
As expected, they fit perfectly, and as I look at myself in the mirror I picture what Spencer would look like when he sees me wearing them.
That’s right. When.
I throw back on my earlier outfit and grab the basket, acting as bored and normal as possible to find him sitting at the kitchen table, reading a book.
“Hey,” I greet him, setting the basket in front of me once I reach the bottom of the stairs. “Everything fits good, I just need them washed now. Could you run these down to the laundry room for me? I think I’m gonna make something to snack on before Mom brings dinner.”
It doesn’t surprise me to see him look at my legs before my face, even if it is brief. I want to smile, but I hold back, watching him nod with a tight smile of his own.
“Sure.”
He disappears and then I wait.
One…
Two…
Three.
I sneak as quietly as I can to the laundry room once I hear the washer door open. I hadn’t specifically asked him to put them in the washer for me on purpose, and it looks like now he’s doing exactly what I thought he might.
My head peeks around the corner, barely in his range of sight as I watch him empty the basket. He takes one item of clothing at a time and throws it in the washer, and halfway through the basket he stops, just to place a pair of my new underwear on the dryer beside him.
My heart races faster the more I wait for him to get to the end of the basket. Once he does, he pauses again, and I think I know exactly what he’s looking for.
Still, he sets the basket aside and picks up the stray pair of underwear, a simple black cotton pair that I’d been getting for years, and drapes it over his hands. My thighs instantly clench, and I try so hard to remain where I am so I can see where he takes this.
He takes it straight to hell, apparently, tentatively pulling his dick out of his pants and gripping it firmly. I can barely see since his back is partially turned, but I see enough, and god he’s so fucking pretty. My underwear dangle from his left hand while the other works slowly over his erection, a soft sigh falling from his lips.
I fight to let one of my own slip as my hand sinks down the front of my body, past the lavender cotton and lace that I know he just wishes he had right now.
And then, a few seconds later he’s already coming, using my brand new underwear to catch each rope of it, and the sight nearly has me on my knees.
And because I want to catch him in the act, I quickly draw my hand away from myself and step into the room, barely giving him time to recover.
“You come fast.”
Spencer looks utterly devastated when he turns to see me standing in the entryway to the laundry room, arms crossed and an amused smirk adorning my face.
“Y/N… I—I… I’m so sorry, I didn’t… I…”
“Don’t worry about it,” I say, taking a step towards him and shrugging. “You heard me, and now I heard you… We’re even. Besides, I… figured you might be looking for these.”
He’s still stunned, but he looks down all the same, watching my hands slip under my skirt and glide the lavender panties down my legs. I step out of them and hold the garment up on one finger, a soft smile still on my face.
“I picked 'em out just for you, you know,” I tell him, tossing them past his face and into the washer. “I’ve noticed that you like purple.”
This time he’s quick to respond. “Y/N, we… We can’t… This isn’t right.”
“Says the man holding my underwear soaked in his cum…”
He looks panicked again, extremely guilty, but if this isn’t going to end in a total disaster, then I have to reassure him that I’m okay.
“Spencer, I’m not mad…” I take another step forward, and it feels much like trying to approach a wounded animal. I can see in his eyes and in his posture that this conflict is killing him, so I decide to show some rapport. “And I know… I know this is messy… I love my mom… And I’m sure you care about her a lot… But are we really going to ignore this? We tried that, remember? And now look where we are.”
“I…” He swallows, shaking his head and trying to avoid my eyes. “I can’t stop thinking about you… I can’t…”
My hand finds his arm, and the light touch has him sighing out, an incredulous, breathy laugh escaping him. “Y/N, please… Don’t.”
“Don’t what?” I ask softly, praying he won’t turn me away. If he does, we’re just back to square one, only the square is jagged, sharper than ever before, and in serious danger of injuring someone.
When he meets my eyes, I see nothing but a desire for something he knows he can’t have. “Don’t want me.”
Now it’s my turn to laugh. My knees start to wobble as I go down, keeping my eyes locked onto his, and I swear I see them dilate fully. I scoot in closer, sliding my hand up his leg and finding the words in my heart to finally say out loud.
“It’s too late for that…”
My face moves closer, and the hand of his that doesn’t currently hold my underwear flies down to gently tug at my hair, keeping me in place.
“If you do this… God, Y/N, I won’t be able to stop myself…”
A smirk dances over my lips as I lean in, breath fanning gently over his exposed skin. “Don’t.”
He swallows. “Don’t what?”
“Don’t stop yourself.”
I barely get the words out before his hand is completely pulling me towards him, and the second my lips press against the silky skin of his hard cock, he loses it completely.
His fingers thread through my hair as I kiss and lick my way softly up to the tip. Once I’m there, I swirl my tongue out and taste the small beads of cum that had remained after he came, a low, satiated hum radiating through my body and making him shiver under my touch.
And then I wrap my lips fully around the head of his dick, and there’s no stopping the most beautiful sound I’ve ever heard come out of his mouth. It’s a broken, desperate whisper of my name. The crack in his voice when he says it spurs me forward, and I take him deeper into my mouth until he hits the back of my throat.
That’s when he tosses my underwear in the washer and uses both of his hands to grab my head, roughly guiding me along his cock and fully taking control of my actions.
The fire in my belly doesn’t ease up, not even once he’s decided that he can’t take it anymore and pulls me off of him harshly.
And that’s only because now he’s fully turned over, finally given into these desires that have been plaguing him presumably from the moment we met.
“I want you stripped and in your bed, on your hands and knees within the next five minutes.”
I get up off the floor and walk up to him until our bodies are flush, my arms reaching up to wrap around his neck.
“What are you gonna do to me, Spencer?”
He searches my eyes, and his own grow dark with the purest form of sin I’d ever seen. And when his hands come up over the back of my legs, and under my skirt to grab my ass and pull me even closer to him, I can’t help the little mewl that slips past my lips.
He smiles, and if it hadn’t been for the grip he held on me, I would have fallen to my knees. “Little girl, when I’m through with you, you’ll have to come up with some excuse to your mom about why you can’t walk straight… Is that what you want?”
The mention of my mom should send me running in the opposite direction, but his threat only prolongs that fire in my veins and makes me want him even more.
I tilt my head up and press a gentle kiss to his lips.
“Do your worst…”
———
Turns out he was very true to his word.
Sitting at the kitchen table is somewhat of a relief, but I try not to walk around as much when Mom gets home. She’d asked me almost immediately if I was okay, and I told her I was just hungry and needed to eat something.
She seemed to have bought it, rushing to the kitchen to unpack the fast food she’d ordered for us. Over her shoulder, Spencer gave me a sly smile, and it took everything I had within myself not to crumble.
Through bites of food, I only half-listen to Mom telling us about the stuff she had to do at work because most of the words I’m hearing are in my head— A loop of endless dirty talk that plants deep into the soil of my stomach and spreads out through my whole body. It infects me, like the most beautiful poison, and I never want it to stop.
“Tell me, sweetheart, you ever let a man come inside you before?”
His weight on top of me coupled together with the heft of his voice has me whining out in pleasure, each snap forward of his hips over my ass as he pounds into me from behind the most delectable burn I’ve ever felt.
“Uh huh,” I answer happily, twisting my head to feel his cheek against my own. “That night you heard me in the shower… I walked through the door with a stranger’s cum soaking my panties… And you know what?”
He grumbles, his hips hitting into me harder as he waits for me to continue.
“I wished it was yours…”
My legs clench together under the table and I take a large gulp of water.
I feel something graze over my bare shin, and I already know it’s Spencer’s foot, a silent reassurance of his presence and that no matter what, he’ll always be here.
“Here’s what’s going to happen…”
He has me on my back now, my legs hoisted over his shoulders and bent back so I’m nearly folded in half. His hips are flush against mine and I can feel his cock throbbing as he comes into the condom.
“You’re gonna make an appointment to make sure you’re clean… You’re gonna make sure you’re on good birth control… And then the next time I fuck this pretty little pussy, you’re gonna really know what it feels like to have a man come inside you.”
Right… Like I really need a reminder of his presence.
I can practically feel it still inside me, taking up every inch of space my body could provide. And no matter how long I go without seeing him, I have no doubt that it’ll always remain.
“But that’s enough about me, I’m sorry.” Mom’s voice shifts and breaks me out of my fantasy. “So, how did your day of bonding go? You have fun?”
Spencer and I share a look, a smile spreading over his lips that makes me smile in turn.
“Yeah, Mom,” I say. “It was great.”
He nods in kind. “Yeah… We’ll definitely have to do it again.”
His foot grazing over my leg under the table cements the unwavering smile on my face, as does the way my whole body burns at the memory of him fucking me upstairs only hours before.
I don’t even flinch or get sick to my stomach when Mom reaches over and gives Spencer a kiss.