Chapter Text
Mike Wheeler was not gay. He had a girlfriend once. Jane. Or El. She didn’t mind which. But he found himself stood in the entrance to a gay club in New York, 1992. He’s 21. He walks to the bar and orders a Vodka Cranberry, and sips it slowly.
He looks across the bar and sees a man who looks familiar. Looks like my Will. He’s hot.
Will was always hot to him. Well. Not always. Cute, then when they were in high school and Mike showed up to California, Thats when he thought Will was hot.
That stupid bowl cut. His stupid hazel green eyes. His stupid bunny teeth. Now he’s thinking of Will in a stupid bunny costume.
But that guy. Is so hot. He looked like Will was a side part/side bang swoop, and a golden hoop earring on his right ear. And rings on his fingers. His hair is slightly longer than Will’s at the back.
Mike found himself, slightly tipsy, walking over to the man. He smiled and sat down next to him.
”Hey, I’m…” this guy could know Nancy. Or Will. Or Lucas. Or max. And tell them he’s at a gay bar. “Jacob.” Middle name. Good.
”I’m,” the man pauses, “Henry,” the man’s face furrowed slightly at his own name.
”I saw you, you look very handsome,” Mike is very bad at flirting. He’s only had a partner when he kissed her first then she disappeared.
”Thanks, you too, I love your curls,” Henry said, reaching to bounce one of the curls. Mike’s hair has grown out a bit more, reaching in a diamond shape to the nape of his neck. Mike smiled, he reached to set a hand on Henry’s arm.
“I love your earring, it suits you,” Mike replied, “Want a drink?”
”No, I don’t really drink, unless it’s a non-alcoholic drink,” Will once said he would never drink, he thought he could end up like Lonnie.
”I can buy a mocktail,” Mike said, “pick what you want,”
”A blueberry and Lemon mocktail,” Henry responded, Will loved Blueberries and Lemons.
”I’ll pay, don’t worry W-Henry,” don’t slip Mike. Mike called over a bartender and ordered two blueberry and Lemon mocktails, he wouldn't drink with a man he wanted to sleep with didn’t want to drink. The bartender nodded and got started on their drinks.
”So, how old are you?” Henry asked.
”21, you?”
”21 as well, you in New York for college?”
”Yeah, I moved college’s to get a better major and I’m meeting some friends tomorrow, you here for college?”
”Yeah, came from Indiana, doing art as my major, you?”
”Im an English lit major, we could make a damn comic together,”
”I love comics!” Henry said, smiling like Will did- same bunny teeth, a little giggle slides out of Henry’s mouth, like Will’s.
”Do you wanna get out of here together?” Mike asked, he doesn’t know if he’ll have sex with Henry or just … take him home and make out and fall asleep together.
”Sure, just let’s get these drinks first?” Henry reminded. Smiling to the bartender as he handed them over.
Mike takes a sip.
”Wow, this is really good, how come I never thought of it?” Mike said.
”Me and my sister E—Jane came up with one summer in 1989. The same summer they all tried Alcohol but Will and Jane made up random mocktails.
”Cool, you talk with her a lot?”
”Yeah, yeah, she’s pretty just me but a girl, when we leave, is it okay if we go to your place? My sister lives with me and I don’t think she’d mind, unless she’s at her boyfriends, we could just head there first, just to check,”
”Yeah sure, if we are going to yours, wanna head to the store to find some condoms? I uh… I’m… whats the word?”
”Top—? Like, you prefer to do everything and be the one inside,”
”Yeah! Yeah, I prefer to do that,”
Mike wasn’t a complete noob to gay sex, he’s hooked up with a couple guys there and then. But he’s not gay. Just … insanely attracted to guys.
They left after Mike paid, walking towards a store down the road, walking inside, the bell above them dinging, they walk to the health aisle and look for the right size.
henry picked up a medium and Mike? Mike was… pretty hefty down there, he was 8 inches soft. Very much. But he was also very girthy.
He had to pick between a large and a king size.
”Wow, hefty? How big is it?”
”8 inches soft and thick,” Mike admitted, feeing himself blush a bit.
”how big is it hard?”
”9.5 inches.”
”Get the king size. Ribbed as well, they’re the best,” Henry told him.
”Experienced eh? Get them for me? You’re closer.”
Henry rolled his eyes and bent over to get the condoms. Henry had the same ass to Will. And the same voice.
mike let it go. A few minutes later they wound up at Henry’s place.
”I need to tell you something, Jacob,” Henry paused as he took his shoes and jacket off.
”Yeah?” Mike said, forgetting his name to Henry was Jacob.
”I’m not Henry. My names Will. Will Byers, I didn’t tell you cause I was worried you would know some of my friends.”
Will. Mike Wheeler is about to hook up with Will Byeee. He knew he looked familiar.
”I knew you seemed familiar, Mike, not Jacob,”
A new expression falls on Will’s face.
”Mike? Oh my god… how did we get here?”
”We could still… hook up, El’s not here right? And we already bought the condoms…” Mike said and put his hand on Will’s arm, stroking it with his thumb softly.
”Mike, I didn’t know you were into guys, never pegged you for being bisexual.”
”I’m— Im not…” Mike felt sick. He couldn’t even say it. He knew he was gay. He never fancied girls. Always preferred to be with boys, found himself buying magazines of men during puberty not Women like Dustin and Lucas were.
”Mike. Hey— you don’t have be gay to like dudes, you can like girls as well,”
”I don’t like girls. I like guys.” Mike admitted after a while.
”You’re gay? Mike, if you told me that when we were 15 I would've pounced on you,” Will admitted.
Mike smiled. Before he knew it, he was holding Will by the waist and kissing him. They were backing up to Will’s bedroom, Will pushing the door open.
Will pulled on Mike’s hair, eliciting a moan out of Mike. Mike bit down on Will’s lip to muffle his own moan causing Will to whimper, his legs caving together slightly.
Mike pushed will onto the bed, pulling the condom boxers out of his pocket.
”You okay bun?” Mike called him Bun without realised.
”Bun? Whats rhat short for?” will asked, giggling softly, if Will had bunny ears he would be using them to cover his adorable bunny smile and teeth.
”Bunny, you got bunny teeth, they’re cute,” Mike said, his cheeks blushing high up.
”What animal are you then?” Will asked, pulling Mike on top of him, rolling them over so they were facing each other.
”I don’t know, what do you think? You know me better than I know myself,” Mike joked and kissed Will’s nose, causing Will to blush.
”hmm, visually? A wolf, Mentally? Golden retriever,”
”I am not a dog—!” Mike whined then Will giggled and kissed Mike; the kiss was soft to start off with then it turned into grabbing and shirts being thrown off, pants as well.
”Socks on or off?” Will asked as Mike kissed down his chest, will threw his head back.
”Off. get too sweaty otherwise,” Mike said as he peeled their socks off.
This is crazy. I’m making out with his best friend as they’re in their boxers. Half an hour ago he thought he would have a meaningless hookup as he thought of Will. Now he was hooking up with Will.
Mike pushed Will against the pillows.
”Can I be inside you? Please Will, let me fill you up,” Mike pleaded as Will sat on his lap and rolled his hips on Mike’s crotch, moaning and whimpering, nodded.
”Okay… take these off baby, hips up for me bun,” Mike said, peeling his own boxers off, his 9.5 inch dick springing out and then Mike pulled Will’s boxers off showing off his 5.5 inch dick.
”You’re so handsome, do you shave?”
”Yeah, I prefer my body bare,” Will mumbled out, his head falling on the nape of Mike’s neck as he grinded down on him.
”Mm, I’m quite hairy down there, and everywhere, I usually have to shave everyday,” Mike admitted, pushing Will off him so he can kiss Will’s neck.
”Dont shave, for one week at least,”
Mike nodded and grabbed a condom.
”Fuck, we forgot lube—”
“Middle drawer—” Will interrupted and Mike grabbed the lube.
”Blueberry huh?” Mike joked.
”What? It reminded me of you, you’re a blue guy,”
”And you’re a yellow guy,” Mike joked back.
Mike trailed his fingers down Will’s back and rrased slightly over the rim.
Will whined loud, his hips slamming onto Mike’s fingers— accidentally shoving them inside him.
”Shit—! Will— you okay?” Mike was only one finger in but he had massive hands.
Will gasped and then he was crying.
”Will! Will—!”
Will was sat on Mike’s hand, not letting him move.
”mmm?”
”Why are you crying?” Mike asked, stilling his fingers
”Cause it feels good,” Will gasped out, trying to get Mike’s fingers to move.
”You okay with me to keep going?”
”mhmm,” Will nodded and grabbed onto Mike’s hair, making him moan. He moved his fingers vigorously to stretch Will out.
He slid a next finger in and scissored them together and out. Will came all over Mike’s stomach, Mike grinned, he pulled his fingers out and stroked them on Will’s cum.
he lifted his fingers to Will’s mouth.
”Suck for me baby,” Mike directed. Will obliged, licking Mike clean, moaning over Mike’s long fingers.
”Ready for me to go inside you?” Mike asked, Will nodded and Mike removed his fingers, Will whined at the loss. “You like having stuff in your mouth?”
Will nodded wirh a whine.
”You in subspace?” Mike asked, his voice softening slightly, Will nodded with a high whimper.
Mike grabbed his own boxers off the bed and put them in will’s mouth for him to suck on. Will moaned happily.
Mike coated his fingers in lube and lubed Will’s hole up, then he put the condom on, coating the ribbed condom in lube to make it easier.
He teased the tip around the rim then slid it in slowly. Will moaned, his eyes rolling back and grabbing the bedsheets.
Mike smirked and inched in slower and slower.
”You feeling good baby? Good for daddy?” Mike didn’t even realise he called himself daddy. Will moaned and nodded, his hips trying to thrust themselves down onto Mike’s dick, trying to push it in, “Now now baby, be patient for daddy, okay? I’m very big and it could hurt you,”
Will whined but obliged, Mike could tell Will loved being told what to do in the bedroom.
Mike slowly pushed 3 inches in of himself, 6.5 more to go.
”God… you’re so tight baby… if you didn’t tell me earlier I would’ve thought you were a virgin at all this,” Mike joked, moving his head to leave marks all over Will’s neck and body
Will whimpered into the boxers and his hips slammed down onto Mike’s cock, screaming into the boxers and tears falling from his eyes.
”Will! God— baby— thumbs up for me if you’re okay and eanna keep going,” Mike was very worried cause Will just shoved a 9.5 cock inside of him.
Will thumbsed up and he was heavily grinding down on Mike. Mike smirked before thrusting to match the rythmn. Trying to find Will’s prostrate.
”Baby— wait— lift your hips for me bunny,” Mike commanded and Will followed, Mike set a pillow underneath Will’s back and then Mike thrusted in and slammed right into Will’s prostate, causing him to moan louder than the boxers in his mouth could handle.
Mike smirked and kept slamming into that one stop, he could feel his own climax on the edge.
”Bun… baby I’m close— so close…fuck…” Mike said as his hips moved more erratically and Will orgasmed on Mike’s stomach. That made Mike finish inside the condom.
Mike slowly pulled out, and took the condom on and shoved it in the bin, then came back to Will to take the boxers out of his mouth.
”Bun, still wirh me?” Mike asked, his voice a lot softer. Will nodded and curled up against Mike. Mike smiled and grabbed some baby wipes from a drawer to clean themselves.
When he went to put the wipes in the bin, Will was sleeping on his chest so Mike just left them on the nightstand as Mike drifted off to sleep.