Work Text:
When you had first come to Air Supplena Island to study hamon under Lisa Lisa, you hadn’t expected to be training with the two rambunctious males standing before you. Joseph and Caesar had come to the island a few days before you, and upon your arrival they had both made it their mission to “woo” you, making it into a competition of sorts. You were not exactly impressed with their efforts, though over time you had grown rather fond of the two men, even if they frequently got on your nerves with their ridiculous “flirting.”
“Hey! Y/N, check this out!” Joseph shouted before attempting to do a backflip off the wall. He had used hamon to help stick his feet to the wall, but unfortunately, he timed the jump wrong and still managed to fall flat on his face. You sighed loudly and rubbed your hand down your face while Caesar let out a loud laugh.
“You’re never gonna impress her like that, Jojo.” Caesar said with a shake of his head.
“Ok, Caesar! How about you do it then, huh?” Joseph challenged the blonde. Caesar only smirked with a small glint of amusement in his eyes. He then proceeded to execute a perfect flip landing on his feet with a bow, and shooting a wink in your direction.
“Could you two stop being idiots for a moment so we can get back to training? Thanks.” you said with a roll of your eyes.
“Anything for you, bella.” Caesar said sweetly, lifting your hand to place a kiss on your knuckles before pulling back into a fighting stance. “Would you like to spar with me?”
You put your finger to your lips miming consideration.
“Actually, why don’t you two spar together? I think you need the training more than me considering you’ve been goofing off all morning.” You say with a smirk.
“Hey! I wasn’t goofing off! I was doing a very important experiment.” Joseph said with a large smile.
“In what world is trying to impress Y/N with your ridiculous poses an ‘important experiment?’ Please, enlighten me.” Caesar replied with a roll of his eyes.
“It was an experiment in human attraction. Y/N is clearly hiding her attraction to me, I was seeing how long before she would admit she was impressed with my sweet muscles.” Joseph smiled proudly, striking a pose and flexing his muscles before Caesar smacked him upside the head.
“Ow! What was that for?”
“For being a dumbass. She’s right, we should train more. She is clearly far more advanced than us in hamon.”
“Hmm, sucking up to me isn’t going to impress me either, Caesar. You’re just as bad as Jojo, you just think you’re slick.” You shake your head at him. He looks a bit offended to be compared to his friend, but before he can argue, you turn around to head to the kitchen to grab a glass of water.
As you turn, you can hear Joseph let out a triumphant laugh.
“Don’t laugh, idiota! She was insulting you too.”
“Wait, what?”
You laugh a bit to yourself as you begin walking down the hallway, their sound of their argument fading.
When you reach the kitchen, you let out a small sigh before grabbing a glass and filling it in the sink. As much as you hated to admit it, you were realizing you may be starting to develop feelings for both men. You had caught yourself blushing when Caesar had told you that you looked beautiful this morning, and you found yourself thinking some.... inappropriate thoughts about Joseph this morning during his little “experiment.”
‘The dude is ripped, okay! It’s natural to feel a little attraction, right?’ you thought to yourself as you took a sip of the water. ‘Shit, I can’t admit anything to either of them or they’ll think they’ve won, and besides that, how am I supposed to choose between them? I feel this way about them both.’ You sighed before setting your head in your hands in frustration.
You allowed yourself a few more minutes of wallowing in self-pity before downing the rest of your water and placing the cup in the sink. You braced your hands on the sink and took a moment to compose yourself before turning around… and running face first into a broad chest.
“Whoa, careful, bella.” Caesar said with a small smile, placing his hands on your arms to help steady you. “I just came to check on you, you were gone for awhile.”
You could feel your cheeks heating up, so you quickly turned back to the sink before he could notice.
“I-I’m fine, I just wanted to rest for a bit. I need to wash my glass and then I’ll come back, ok?” you tell him.
“Alright, I’ll head back then. I probably shouldn’t have left Jojo without supervision, who knows what he’ll get into while I’m gone.”
You laugh at that, and he smiles. He adores the way you laugh, especially when you laugh for him. It makes his heart feel warm and he wants nothing more than to make you laugh again and again. He knows you think that he and Joseph are only flirting with you as some sort of competition, and perhaps it had started out that way, but he found himself quickly falling for you as he got to know you. He had also discovered that Joseph felt much the same way about you that he did. He wasn’t entirely sure what he was going to do with that yet, but he had an idea brewing in his mind. He just needed to run it by Joseph first.
He gives your arm a soft squeeze before turning and leaving. You watch him leave and let out a huff of breath before beginning to wash your glass. While you were busy with that, Caesar and Joseph were busy scheming.
You dried the glass and your hands before heading back to the training room, where you found Caesar messing around with a record player. He spent a few minutes searching through a stack of records before he found one that seemed to please him, letting out a small hum in approval. He spun the record in his hands before setting it on the player and setting the needle on it. A slow and romantic sounding tune began to fill the room. You looked at him in confusion before he waltzed over to you and held his hand out with a bow and a small smile on his face. You hesitated for a bit before gently placing your hand into his.
He straightened back up, pulling you closer to him. He placed your other hand over his shoulder before winding his arm around your waist. A slight blush rose to your cheeks as you let him just hold you for a moment.
“Caesar, what’s going on?” you ask a confused look on your face. He just shushes you before beginning to sway slowly. He removes his hand from your waist and lifts your arm to spin you around before pulling you back to his chest and dipping you. You let out a small yelp feeling yourself falling from his grip before another set of strong arms grab you before you can hit the ground.
Your eyes widen a bit in surprise before Joseph lifts you up bridal style. In your shock, you had absentmindedly wrapped your arms around his neck to prevent yourself from falling and he smiled triumphantly.
“I knew you’d fall for me eventually!” He says with a wink and a laugh. You just blink at him in confusion before turning back to Caesar to see him directing a seething glare at Joseph.
“What the hell, Joseph! You made me drop her! What if she got hurt?”
“Oh shut up, I only did that because you were hogging her! I didn’t even get to say anything to her before you swooped her up like some sort of stupid cassanova or something.” Joseph says pouting his lips.
“What the hell are you guys even talking about? What’s going on?” you tried to extract yourself from Joseph so you could stand on your own, but he only pulled you tighter to him. You let out a small squeak as your face was pressed into the crook of his neck. The two men ignored your questions and continued their bickering.
“Joseph you’re totally ruining this! It would have been much better if you had just let things play out the way I suggested.” Caesar said, crossing his arms in frustration.
“If we did things your way, you get to hog her the whole time! It’s not fair, I want to have time with her too.” Joseph says turning you slightly away from Caesar protectively.
You peeked around Joseph to look at Caesar.
“What is he talking about? Stop talking about me like I’m not even here!” You said angrily, finally managing to extract yourself from Joseph. You placed your hands on your hips and glared at Caesar.
Joseph pouted a bit about you leaving his grasp, but he remained silent, waiting for Caesar to speak.
Caesar sighed before running his hand down his face and murmuring some curses in Italian under his breath.
“Well, this was supposed to go much differently, but I suppose I couldn’t expect things to go smoothly with Jojo around.” Joseph opened his mouth to protest but Caesar lifted his hand, silencing him.
“Y/N, I…we...um,” He struggles a bit with coming up with the right words. He had planned for this to go much differently, and this would have been much easier to say if things had gone his way.
Joseph sighs before piping in, “We both like you.”
Your eyebrows furrowed in confusion and you looked at them both before slowly starting, “Okaay? I like you guys too? But what does that have to do with all of…this?”
“No, no.” Caesar mumbles a few more Italian curses before continuing. “Not like that, he means we both have feelings for you.”
Your eyes widened and you looked between the two men. You knew they both enjoyed flirting with you, but you figured it was because they liked the competition, not because they actually had any interest in you. You contemplated that perhaps this was some sort of prank before Joseph spoke up.
“Do you.... have feelings for us?” Joseph asks a bit sheepishly, rubbing the back of his neck. You had never seen him look so nervous, and it hit you at that moment that they must be serious.
“I-I um, m-maybe... yeah.” You crossed your arms over your chest, looking away shyly, feeling your face burning up.
“Both of us?” Caesar questions you further, his voice a bit tentative.
You hesitate, hunching over further into yourself.
“Y-yeah…” you finally sputter out. You expected them to be unhappy with your response. You figured they would be disappointed to find out you didn’t favor one of them over the other, but to your surprise, Caesar smiled brightly at you while Joseph cheered, scooping you up into his arms again.
“So do you want to be our girlfriend?” He asks, beaming down at you.
“Our girlfriend?” you repeat. “Y-you both want to date me? At the same time?”
“Yeah!”
“Oh…” you stop for a moment to consider this, placing your fingers to your lips, before you answer.
“O-ok.”
“Are you sure?” Caesar questions, gently brushing your hair behind your ear and resting his hand on your cheek. He wanted to make sure that this is what you truly want. He didn’t want you to feel pressured to be with both of them just to avoid hurting one, or both, of them. You nod, turning your head into Joseph’s chest to hide your blushing face. A small blush rises to Joseph’s face as you snuggle into him. He can’t believe you were his now! Granted, he had to share you with Caesar, but to his surprise, that didn’t bother him in the slightest. If he was going to be honest, it just felt right to share you with Caesar.
Caesar and Joseph smile at each other before Joseph sets you down, and offers you his hand. You take Joseph’s hand and Caesar gently takes your other hand. Joseph pulls you into his chest, smiling down at you, as he wraps his arm around your waist. Caesar presses himself against your back, wrapping his arm around you as well and placing his chin into the crook of your neck. He places a gentle kiss to your neck and you shiver before the two men begin to sway to the music that continued to play in the background. Eventually, they spin you, switching their positions so you are pressed to Caesar’s chest while Joseph holds you from behind. Joseph gently nips your earlobe and you gasp. Both men chuckle lighty at your reaction.
“Do you like that?” Joseph breathes before nipping your ear again. You shiver and nod your head eagerly. He moves his lips to your neck and you can feel him smirk against your skin as he trails heated kisses from just below your ear to your collarbone.
Caesar smirks at your reactions to Joseph before he gently lifts your chin. He places a soft kiss to your lips, waiting for you to return it before sliding his hand into your hair tilting your head back so he can deepen the kiss. His other hand wraps tighter around your waist, pulling you closer to him. A small moan escapes your lips and Caesar smiles into the kiss before gently biting your lower lip. Not to be outdone, Joseph brushes your hair away from your neck before gently nipping and sucking at the sweet spot on your neck. You tilt your head further to the side giving him easier access as you tangle your fingers into Caesar’s hair. He groans quietly, slipping his tongue into your mouth and you gasp as his hands slide down to your hips.
Caesar pulls away from the kiss for a moment to allow the both of you to catch your breath. He cups your face with his palm and looks deep into your eyes.
“You’re so perfect, bella. I could kiss you forever and never grow tired of the taste of your lips.”
His words light a fire in your body and you move to kiss him again, but before you can reach his lips, Joseph scoffs and picks you up, throwing you over his shoulder.
“You’re so corny, Caesar.” Joseph slaps your ass and starts to take off down the hallway.
“Hey! Put me down!” you protest punching his back. He only laughs and continues down the hallway. You look back to Caesar to see him miming strangling Joseph. You snort out a laugh and he sends you a wink. Joseph whips around, to see what you and Caesar are laughing at and the motion makes you feel slightly dizzy.
“What are you guys laughing at?” he questions with a pout.
“Nothing! Stop moving like that, it’s making me dizzy…” you say holding your head. You can hear Caesar swear a bit, and the sound of what you can only assume is him facepalming.
“Oh…I’m sorry! I didn’t mean to do that, I’ll be more careful.” Joseph says as he slowly turns back around continuing down the hallway.
“Where are we going anyway?” you ask.
Joseph only snickers, before you hear him open a door. He takes you into the mystery room, and Caesar follows, shutting the door behind the three of you. Joseph flops you down onto something soft and you realize you are in his bedroom. He climbs onto the bed and moves on top of you.
“C-can I kiss you?” he asks, a bit shyly. You were a bit surprised that he took the time to ask for permission after carrying you here against your will, but you were glad that he did. You nodded and his eyes lit up before he pressed his lips to yours. His kiss was a bit more sloppy than Caesar’s but still very pleasant. Joseph pressed himself closer to you and you wrapped your legs around his waist, causing him to gasp. He ran his hands down your arms and threaded his fingers in between yours, pinning your hands to the bed. You groaned and rutted your hips into his. He mumbled a quiet “fuck” into your mouth before rolling his hips against yours. You moaned and arched your back into the bed.
You felt another weight shift the bed before you felt a hand gently running through your hair as you and Joseph continued to make out and grind against each other. You pulled away from the kiss to look at Caesar and Joseph moved his lips to your neck. Caesar’s emerald eyes reflected nothing but adoration as he placed a kiss to your forehead. Joseph placed one more kiss to your lips before rolling off of you.
Caesar took this opportunity to pull you into his lap, threading one hand into your hair and gripping your hip with the other. You placed both of your arms around his neck and bit your bottom lip. He looked you over hungrily before meeting your eyes. You pressed your lips to his and began moving your hips against him, desperate to get back the delicious friction you had been building up with Joseph. He pulled back from the kiss and chuckled, his eyes darkened with lust.
“Eager, are we?” he asked, placing both hands on your hips to aid you in your movements. You blushed and turned your head away from him shyly.
Your eyes landed on Joseph, who smirked at you before slowly pulling his shirt over his head. He struck a pose and winked at you. You bit your lip and looked over his body hungrily.
“Like what you see?” he asked cheekily.
“Mmm, yeah. You’re so hot, Jojo.” you gasped out. He hadn’t been expecting you to be so bold in your response and his mouth dropped open in surprise. You giggled at him before turning back to Caesar.
“I think you need to lose some of your clothes too.”
You pulled at the hem of his shirt, helping him lift it over his head. You licked your lips and placed your palms on his abs, slowly sliding them up his perfectly sculpted chest. He shuddered, his eyes locked on your movements. You moved your hands behind his neck before pulling him back into a kiss. His lips moved against yours slowly and sensually and you could feel his hands sliding up your shirt, taking in the softness of your skin. He moved his hands back down, and you could feel them tugging at the hem of your shirt.
“Your turn.” he tells you, his voice filled with lust. You nod and he helps you slide your shirt over your head. He looks over your body appreciatively, murmuring “so beautiful.” You hear a low whistle from Joseph and you turn your head to smirk at him.
“Like what you see?” you ask him, mimicking his question from earlier.
“Fuck yeah.” he breathes out.
You chuckle before turning back to Caesar, he pulls you back into a kiss, sliding his tongue into your mouth. You moan and grind your hips against his again.
You hear a noise of protest from Joseph, and you and Caesar both come up with the same idea to torment Joseph by putting on a little show.
“Mmm Caesar, you feel so good~” you moan out. He grips your hips tighter, pushing you down onto him and you both moan. You slide your hand into his hair and gently tug his head back so you can deepen the kiss. Your other hand travels down his chest to the hem of his pants. You rub your thumb along the sensitive area right above the hem of his pants and you can feel his breath catch as he shivers. You smirk before moving your lips to his neck, and then down his body to just below his navel. He watches you hungrily, licking his lips in anticipation.
You hook your fingers into the waistline of his pants, and he lifts his hips so you can slide them off of him. You can see his cock is already hard and straining against his boxers.
“Fuck Caesar, you’re so big. I can’t wait for you to fuck me~” you breathe out, slightly wiggling your ass in Joseph’s direction. You can hear him whine from behind you, but he still makes no move to interfere. You suppose you’ll have to up the ante a bit.
“Mmm, I bet you’ll feel so fucking good stretching out my tight pussy. I’m so wet just thinking about you, Caesar.” you purr. Despite knowing your words are partly only meant to rile up Joseph, Caesar can’t help but moan at them.
It’s at this point that Joseph has had enough. He pulls you off of Caesar and pins you to the bed with a frown on his face.
“What about me?” he asks, pouting his lips out at you. You laugh and kiss him. He lets go of your hands so he can run them over your sides and he deepens the kiss. You reach your hands down to his waist to find he has already stripped down to his boxers. You slide your hand down and grope him through the fabric and you hear his breath catch. A smirk crosses your lips and you begin to stroke him through his boxers. He bucks his hips into your hands and whines, desperate for more. You gently push him off of you so you can move to straddle his hips, but before you can, Caesar pulls you down so you are lying on your back on the bed.
The two men smirk at each other.
“I think we’ve had enough of your teasing.” Caesar says, moving to pull off your bottoms. Once they’re off, Caesar moves to kiss your neck as you feel Joseph’s fingers teasing at the hem of your panties. He quickly runs his fingers over your crotch through the fabric and you buck your hips up into his hand with a desperate whine. He snickers before pulling your panties completely off. He slides his finger through your folds and smirks when he sees how wet you are.
“Damn baby, you’re already this wet for us?” he teases.
“Tsk, tsk, so eager.” Caesar adds.
You blush and push your legs together, suddenly feeling a bit self-conscious with both of their attention on you.
“Ah, ah, ah. I don’t think so. You don’t get to pretend to be shy, not after that little show you put on.” Joseph scolds you, gently pushing your legs apart again. He slowly slides one finger down to your entrance and you whimper in anticipation. He bites his lip and watches your face, loving the way you react to some simple teasing. When he finally slides his finger into you, you moan and arch your back into the bed. He slowly begins pumping his finger into you, while Caesar moves to remove your bra.
“M-more Jojo, please more, I need it.” you beg. He obliges, adding a second finger and speeding up his pace. Meanwhile Caesar’s lips latch onto one of your nipples and he gently sucks at it, careful not to apply too much pressure. You gasp and thread your fingers into his hair, your other hand tightly gripping the sheets. When Joseph places his lips over your clit and sucks it into his mouth, you feel like you’re seeing stars. Your back arches into the sheets and you moan loudly, your free hand moving to Joseph’s hair. He hums in satisfaction and the sensation makes you writhe in the sheets again. His fingers continue to work you up into a frenzy, hitting that sweet spot inside of you over and over again as his tongue swirls around your clit.
Caesar continues to grope and squeeze your breasts as his lips move to your ear, gently nipping at your earlobe as he whispers sweet praises to you in Italian. You can’t understand his words, but they send a delicious heat through you nonetheless. As the two men continue to work you, you can feel yourself getting close, your walls clenching down on Joseph’s fingers.
“F-fuck, I’m so close. P-please don’t stop, please, please, please.” you choke out, desperately clutching at both of the men’s hair.
Joseph gives you a few more pumps and a sweet kiss to your inner thigh before pulling his fingers out of you. You whine in protest, but Caesar shushes you with a kiss.
“Shh shh, bella. We’ll give you something much better. Be patient.” he says, planting a soft kiss to the top of your head. Both men proceed to remove their boxers, releasing their hard cocks and you can’t help but let your mouth drop open in surprise. Both of them were freaking hung. Joseph smirks at you and gives himself a few pumps, loving the way your eyes hungrily follow his movements.
You sit up and slowly crawl over to Joseph. You lick your lips before moving to place a kiss to the tip of his dick. You hear him let out a hiss as you slide your tongue over the slit before taking the tip into your mouth. You reach your hand out to Caesar, motioning him to move closer as you give Joseph's cock a hard suck. He obliges, and you take his cock into your hand slowly pumping it as you take more of Joseph’s cock into your mouth. Both men moan loudly and you hum in satisfaction. The sensation makes Joseph hiss and you begin to quickly bob your head up and down on him.
“Shit! Fuck! That feels so g-good, Y/N. Oh my god~” Joseph moans out, throwing his head back in pleasure. You moan against his cock, his reactions sending waves of desire through you. This all feels too good for Joseph and he knows if he lets you continue he won’t last much longer. It takes a great amount of self-restraint, but me manages to gently pull you off his cock, Caesar follows suit and pulls his cock out of your grip.
You cross your arms over your chest and pout, Joseph laughs at your childish display before moving behind you and pulling your back against his chest, both of you in a sitting position with you between Joseph’s legs. He nips at your neck and cups your breasts, his large hands completely covering them. His hands are warm and rough and you moan as he begins to knead them. Caesar takes this time to move himself between your legs, sliding his cock between your wet folds before lining himself up at your entrance.
“Are you ready, bella?” You nod enthusiastically and he slowly slides the tip in. You gasp and lean back into Joseph. Caesar gives you a moment to adjust before he slowly slides himself in a bit at a time. Once he is fully sheathed inside of you, you both gasp and moan. You move your hips against him, encouraging him to start moving. He slides his cock in and out of you at a sinfully slow pace and you whimper, digging your hands into his back. You slam your hips down against him as best you can, and he takes that as his cue to speed up.
“Oh god, Caesar that’s so good. Mmm just like that, god yes! Don’t stop!” you moan out desperately. He looks at you, his face twisted in pleasure as he continues to thrust into you. Joseph continues fondling your breasts and he whispers into your ear.
“Mmm, you’re doing so good baby. Taking his cock so good, I can’t wait for you to take mine. Are you gonna beg for me like that too? I bet you’ll sound so sweet begging for me to fuck you.”
Joseph’s words sent a jolt of heat through you and you moan, turning your face so you can kiss his jaw as he continues to touch you. Caesar lifts your legs up over his shoulders and you gasp and moan as he hits that perfect spot inside of you. Joseph slides one of his hands down to your clit and rubs fast circles across it. You gasp and your walls clench tighter around Caesar.
“Shit bella, you feel so good, I can barely take it. You’re so tight and wet for me.” Caesar moans out. Between his thrusts and Joseph’s fingers on your clit, you can tell you won’t last much longer.
“C-Caesar, I-I’m so close, please don’t stop.” you whine out. Caesar bites his lip as he grips your hips harder, his movements becoming more erratic. Joseph begins moving his hand faster and you arch your back up into him. “Mmpff, Jojo!”
“Mmm yeah, say my name Y/N. Cum for us baby, you’re so sexy like this. I wanna see you cum.” Joseph whispers against your neck. His words are enough to push you over the edge. You gasp and desperately grasp at Caesar’s back as you cum hard around his cock, your pussy tightening and milking him until he cums along with you. He gives you a few more thrusts to ride out both of your orgasms before he stops. You both take a moment to catch your breath as Joseph plants soothing kisses along your neck. You smile at Caesar and gently brush some hair out of his face before cupping his cheek. He places a sweet kiss to your lips before pulling out of you and laying down next to you, sending a smug smirk and a wink to Joseph.
Joseph scoffs and rolls his eyes, before nipping your ear, remembering how you had reacted when he had first done it. You gasped and pushed yourself back closer against him. He reached back down to your core and rubbed slow circles into your clit. You twitched and whined, still a bit over-stimulated from your previous orgasm. He pressed a soothing kiss to the side of your head, continuing his slow movements. You groaned and turned slightly so you could nuzzle into his neck. A blush rose to his cheeks at how sweet and intimate you were being with him.
He used his free hand to tilt your head up towards his. He kissed you slow and sweet, and you turned further towards him, your arms snaking around the back of his neck. He moved his hands to wrap around you, pulling you closer to him. You shifted yourself until you were fully straddling his lap and he pulled you tightly against him. You broke the kiss to reach your hand between the two of you and line him up at your entrance. You leaned back into the kiss and slammed yourself down onto him causing him to gasp loudly and you to bite down onto his lower lip.
You threaded one hand into his hair and left the other draped around his back. You pulled his hair to tilt his head back so you could deepen the kiss before you began moving. He hissed into your mouth before harshly gripping your hips and helping lift you up and down his length. When he thrusted hard up into you, you let out a desperate and loud moan. He smirked at you.
“Oh, you like that?” he asked before wrapping his arms around you tighter and thrusting hard up into you over and over again.
“F-fuck, Jojo, yes! Just like that! Oh my god, yes, yes, yes…” you trailed off your mouth hanging open in pleasure as he fucked you. He gave you a few more thrusts before you felt Caesar move around to the back of you. Joseph pulled you back into a heated kiss, cupping the back of your head as Caesar gripped your hips lifting you up and down on Joseph. You and Joseph both moaned into your kiss, desperately grabbing at each other, aching for more of each other. You felt Caesar begin placing kisses along your neck and groping your breasts as you took over moving on Joseph again.
“You’re so beautiful like this, bella...So sweet and good for us.” he whispered while placing a soft kiss against the back of your neck. You shivered and leaned back against him. Joseph gave you a particularly hard thrust at just the right angle and you practically screamed his name.
“Mmm yeah, that’s right Y/N. You like that? Tell me how bad you want me.” Joseph purred, watching your face contort in pleasure.
“Y-yes, that’s so good Jojo! I want more, p-please, more. I n-need more. I want you so bad, p-please!” you whimpered out. He smirked at you before picking up his pace, leaving you a moaning mess. Caesar moved one hand down to your clit rubbing gentle circles, careful not to be too rough since you were still a bit sensitive. You buried your face into Joseph’s neck to help steady yourself as you could feel your orgasm building much quicker this time.
“I-I t-think I-I’m gonna cum.” you warned him as you could feel the tightening in your core.
“Then cum for me, baby.” Joseph gasped out.
You gasped into his neck calling his name over and over again as you felt yourself go over the edge. You could feel his hips stuttering as you tightened around him. He helped you ride out the rest of your orgasm before you felt him tensing and his hips barely moving. You took over riding him to help him finish as he buried his head in your neck, desperately gasping as he came hard. You both sat there for a few moments resting your foreheads against each other and panting before you finally moved off of him, Caesar helping lift you.
Joseph leaned back in the bed and placed both hands over his face laughing.
“Wow, that was AMAZING. I really didn’t think she’d agree to that.”
He looked at you in wonder before adding, “you’re amazing you know that? Wow.”
Caesar laughed before pulling you under the sheets of the bed and against him so he was spooning you.
“You really are amazing, Y/N.” he added, placing a soft kiss on your shoulder. A deep blush rose up on your cheeks and you covered your face with your hands, a bit embarrassed by all of their praise.
“Y-you guys were pretty good too…” you said quietly.
Joseph moved under the covers on the other side of you and pulled your hands away from your face. You looked up at him and saw a large smile on his face.
“Come on, don’t be shy after all of that!” he laughs before snuggling into your chest. You gently run your fingers through his hair and he hums contentedly. Caesar snuggles tighter against your back.
“I love you, bella.” he murmurs into the back of your neck.
“I love you too, Y/N!” Joseph looks up at you, a dopey smile on his face.
“I love you guys too.” you smile and close your eyes in bliss. You couldn’t believe you had been so hesitant to give in to the two of them before. Everything about this felt so comfortable and right and you couldn’t imagine yourself ever being happier than you were right now, cuddled up between these two men.
“Sooo, is this proof that my experiment worked? You were totally wooed by my muscles, right?” Joseph asks and you laugh, while Caesar reaches over to smack him.
“Hey! Don’t hate me ‘cause I’m beautiful!” Joseph says ducking away from Caesar’s hand.
“You’re an idiot is what you are!” Caesar yells at him.
You snicker at them, and think to yourself, ‘yeah, I really could spend the rest of my life like this.’ You pull both of them back down to cuddle with you again, and the three of you fall asleep like that, tangled together and content with each other’s company.