Chapter Text
During the mission, you got badly injured and had to stay at the hospital wing for a about a week. You couldn’t go on any missions, so two men you know very well decided to take care of you. Despite being engaged again, Eren wouldn’t stop trying to win your heart. He’d always bring you flowers and hold your hand wanting you to choose him instead of the captain but you couldn’t choose. You truly loved them both. Levi did not like this at all. He wished Eren would stop trying to get with his fiancé again and again. But one thing the two men can agree on is your safety. They were both worried sick when you got hospitalized. Eren and Levi would go visit you whenever they could, constantly bumping into each other. Eren had immense respect for his captain but when it came to you, he couldn’t hold back his tongue. Levi always felt that Eren would one day save humanity, but that doesn’t mean he’s allowed to fuck around with his soon-to-be wife.
Day 1 At The Hospital Wing:
“Yeager,” Levi spoke entering the wing with a gift basket of your favorite treats. “Captain.” Eren greeted him back with his own gift basket of flowers. They walked into your room and Levi kissed you. “How’re you feeling?” Eren spoke up making Levi glare at him. “I’ve been the best I can be. I hope I get out of here soon.” You smiled weakly and at one of the candies from Levi’s basket. “I’ll treat you to dinner at Nicollo’s restaurant once you get out of here.” Levi gave you a small smile and Eren rolled his eyes. He grabbed the captain’s arm and looked him straight in the eyes. “We should let her rest.” Levi stared back and said, “Yes we should.” And the two walked away leaving an exhausted you behind.
Day 2 At The Hospital Wing:
“Morning Levi!” You smiled as you saw your fiancé enter the room you were staying in. “Morning.” He spoke softly and placed down the books he brought you on your bedside table. He knew you would get bored in here so he wanted to make sure it wasn’t horrible. “Any better today?” Levi asked placing a hand on your cheek. “Yeah, seeing you and Eren lifts my spirits!” You grin and kiss his cheek. “Eren couldn’t come today, he had a mission,” Levi spoke a little too happily. “Aw that’s too bad, I wanted to say hi.” You frowned and picked up one of the books Levi brought you “Peter Pan? I’m not a kid!” You laughed as Levi said, “You sure act like one.”
Day 3 At the Hospital Wing:
“Hey, doll.” You hear a certain brunette greet as he entered your room. “Oh Hey, Eren! I missed you.” You smiled as he hugged you, but it was definitely not the kind friends gave. “I missed you too. When do you think you're getting out of here?” He asked taking a seat next to your bed. “I dunno, maybe in a couple of days...” You mumbled lost in your thoughts until Eren suddenly stands up. “What if I break you out of here?” He smiled deviously and so did you. Later that day you and Eren ran off giggling like maniacs.
Day 5 At The Hospital Wing:
You hear the door open excitedly waiting to find out who visited you today, Eren or Levi. “Hey my love, I just came back from a mission and couldn’t wait to see you.” You burst into laughter at the terrible impression of Levi. The door fully opens to reveal one of your oldest friends, Hange. “Sorry I haven’t been able to visit you! Commander work has been keeping me real busy.” You smile and hug them. “Have you chosen yet?” Hange asked with a burst of energy. “Chosen what?” You ask feeling a little confused. “Between the two guys of course!!!” Hange gets closer to you hoping they get an answer. “How do you even know about that!?” You grabbed them by the shoulders. “People talk.” Hange laughed and made their way to the door. “What do you mean??” People knew about what was going on in your love life? They probably think you’re a whore now. You frowned at the thought. “You’ll understand when you come came to work.”
Day 7 At The Hospital Wing:
“You are free to go! Hope you have a speed recovery (Y/N). And also, I personally think Eren is a better fit for you! He’s quite handsome! And deserves a beautiful lady like you!” The nurse told you as you packed your things. Before you could ask her how she knew, she left. She probably knows from the constant visits those two troublemakers did. “Ready to go?” Eren asked as he entered the room grabbed one of your boxes. “Yup. Where’s Levi?” You asked and Eren sighed, “He’s driving.” You gasped and a smile crept its way on your face. “You two are working together??” You couldn’t hide the excitement in your voice, and Eren just nodded. You jumped in joy.
“Hey Levi,” You smiled as you got into the automobile kissing him. “I always feel like a third wheel around you two,” Eren grumbled, crossing his arms. “You wouldn’t if you didn’t insist on coming every damn time.” Levi looked at the titan shifter with a glare. “Boys, let’s not forget our objective for today. Let’s get to work with all our limbs intact please.” Levi turns his face back to the road and Eren looked out the window.
By the time you reached the base, you could hear tons of whispers and giggles as you walked by. Since it was lunch hour, you made your way to the cafeteria, where you were greeted by Armin and Mikasa as well as a few others. They all looked at you expectantly and you just looked around very confused. “What’s going on guys?” You smiled sheepishly as Armin pulled you aside. “Miss, have you chosen yet? Everyone is awaiting your answer!” Armin smiled just a bright as the sun. “Who do you want me to choose Arlert?” Pink dusted his cheeks as he said, “Eren of course... but you and Captain Levi make quite the pair.” It was like he couldn’t decide either, which seemed to be the case for many people. That’s why they all wanted you to choose so badly. You walked back to Eren and Levi and told them, “Why is everyone making a huge deal over this...” You groaned and covered your face with your hands.
“Eren is the taller one! His height matches Miss (Y/N)’s perfectly!” A voice in the crowd called out from the right. “But Captain Levi has been dating her since Eren was a cadet! They have years worth of history and love for each other!” Another voice yelled from the left this time. “Oh my fucking god. We are not doing this anymore. I am breaking up with both of them! I choose me! Fuck choosing between men!” You gave Levi his ring back and glared at Eren heading back to your room. “God she’s hot,” Eren said under his breath but the clean freak beside him heard. “Shut up Yeager.”
Once the commotion outside died down you could finally leave your room again. You didn’t understand why they were making such a big deal over this, so you left to your room and unpacked your belongings happy to be back. “I get your decision. If I had to choose between those two, I’d choose me too!” You heard Hange walk in and close the door, as they jumped on your bed and laid down. “I just want life to go back to normal, this drama is so unnecessary. I don’t want to choose and I don’t have to.” You huffed as you placed the book Levi got you on your shelves.
“You love both of them, don’t you,” Hange said with a small smile on their face. You sighed and looked at the Peter Pan book, and a bouquet in front of you. “Yes, I do. They’re both wonderful men, but I can’t choose between them. I love them equally.” You hugged the roses and book with furrowed brows. “Then don’t choose, keep both!” Hange suggested with a grinned face, they jumped out of your bed and grabbed your shoulders. You just shook your head and looked down. “I’ll be fine on my own.” Hange hugged you and you hugged them back. “You will.”
After a couple of hours of solitude, you decided it was time to stop secluding yourself from your problems. You took a deep breath and placed your hand on your handle, but before you could open the door the door was opened by someone on the other side. You look up to see none other than Eren accompanied by Levi. “What are you two doing here...” You asked as they walked inside and close the door behind them. “We want you to decide.” Eren started staring you straight in the eyes. “And what better way to do that than with proving ourselves.” Levi started taking off his coat, as did Eren. “Can you stop this bullshit already! I already said I’m not going to choose!” Eren and Levi stopped mid-tracks and watched you. “I love the both of you, I refuse to choose.” You stood up straight holding your head high. Levi smiled as did Eren.
“We love you as well, which is why I won’t make you choose. Instead, have both of us.” Eren grinned stepped closer to you. “I’d be willing to try, only for you.” Levi began to take off his shirt. They got closer and closer until the back of your knees hit the bed and you fell on it. “H-How is this even going to work?” You chuckled nervously as the two men made their way closer to you. You were shaking of both nerves and excitement. Seeing these god-like men walking toward you filled you to the brim with joy. “Use your imagination doll...” Eren said as he pressed his lips against yours, savoring the taste.
“Don’t hog her Yeager. Remember our terms.” Levi said pulled Eren away from you, bringing you to your feet. “Now, stand right here,” Levi ordered and obeyed on auto-pilot. He then stood in front of you kissing you deeply, then you feel a body press against you from behind. Eren put his hands on your hips pushing your waist and back against his chest. The feeling was incredible. His muscular body against your back and Levi kissing you and holding you from the front. Why haven’t you tried this earlier?
Levi continued to kiss you and Eren hands wandered upwards cupping your breasts in his hands. He squeezed and rugged them, messing with them at every angle. His fondling made light gasps leave your lips. The Levi began to kiss down your jaw, lips trailing down your neck where he stopped. “Y-You guys are too good at this...” You whispered as Eren got rid of your pants, leaving you only in your underwear. “We want to pleasure the woman we love as best as we can,” Levi said muffled against your skin making you pant a little. Eren’s hand slipped in your underwear, and he started rubbing your clit in gentle circles. “E-Eren...” You moaned as the titan shifter smirked as you falling apart for him. “Eyes on me princess.” You hear Levi sternly say as you realized he was no longer kissing you, instead he was unbuckling his jeans and got ready to face fuck you.
Levi took out his dick and placed it in front of your face. “You did this to me, and you need to take responsibility for it. Got it?” Levi grabbed your hair gently as you took him in as best you good. “Atta girl...” He mumbled caressing your face. Eren kept his hands busy and pleasuring you're making you moan on Levi’s cock. Eren kisses along your neck his hands didn’t falter when you felt yourself nearing your orgasm. “E-Eren!” You moan, your voice muffled.
“You’re moaning his name when I’m about to be balls deep inside of you?” Levi scoffed and started thrusting his hips forward making you choke. “That’s what you get.” Eren holds you as you tremble, ready to cum at any minute. “Cum for me doll.” He whispered in your ear. You moan loudly into Levi’s dick making him cum from the vibration. Levi grunts pulling out of you with a smile on his face. “I can never get tired of that mouth of yours.” He says slightly out of breath. “Isn’t it my turn for some fun?” Eren grumbles, feeling his cock throb in his underwear.
“Do you want me Eren?” You ask with an ‘innocent’ look on your face, making him gulp. “Quite a lot actually.” He lets out a nervous laugh as you push him on the bed. “I usually like being on top but since it’s you doll, I’ll let it slide.” Eren winked as he placed his hands behind his head relaxing. You ran your hands down his chest, taking off his underwear and springing free his throbbing cock. Levi was catching his breath on the other side of the bed taking a break. “You sure are excited, aren’t you?” You ask Eren as he shuddered when you grabbed his dick. “Get on with it!” Eren groaned wanting to feel you around him already. “Fine.” You grinned as you place your legs on both sides of his hips, hovering right above him. You centered it then lowered your hips feeling him fill you completely. “You always feel so good...” Eren shivered and you lifted yourself again before going back down. You moved your hips around while he’s inside you and you loved the view. Eren face was flushed red as his hands reached for your hips.
“Want me to h-help you?” He asked lifting you and letting you fall back down. Your eyes rolled back as you rode him. Eren lifted his hips as well to add more friction so he could thrust faster. You moaned as you felt him twitch inside you. “That’s it... Ride me like the good doll you are...” You leaned down and captured his lips with yours and he immediately ran a hand through your hair kissing you harder. The combination of the pleasure and your lips molding together was the final push. You let out a moan and you clamped down on him hitting your peak. Eren not long after pulled you out and came on his stomach. “Wow...” He spoke out of breath and you panted heavily. “As much as I hate sloppy seconds, I believe it’s my turn,” Levi spoke up walking toward you. “I want to enjoy this too.” Eren and Levi looked at each other and smirked. You just shivered in excitement.
“Alright (Y/N). Turn over for me.” Levi ordered, and you obeyed. You laid on the bed on your hands and knees. “Eren you know what do to.” Levi nodded at the brunette and he smirked. “Yes, Captain.” You gulped as Levi pressed against you from behind. You could feel his hard cock begging for attention. Eren sat in front of you and waved. “Now that you have both of us, are you happy?” Levi asked teasing your cunt with his tip. “Or would you like Jean or even Connie to join us, you slut.” A slap landed on your ass and you shook feeling yourself throb yet again. “Are you ready?” Levi asked and you nodded. “Here we go then...” He slowly pushed himself in you stretching you ever so slowly. “You’re taking me so well...” He muttered grabbing your hips keeping you in place. Just to spite you, he thrusted as slow as he could never increasing the pace. “Levi!” You whine as he ignores you. “Eren watch how she falls apart just within a few minutes. You could learn a thing or two.” Eren swallowed as he saw your lewd expression.
Levi was right, you did fall apart for him. Eren just felt himself get hard again. “Need some attention too, Yeager? Go on, her mouth is open.” Levi slapped your ass again making you open your mouth to let out a gasp. You gasp was interrupted but Eren’s dick getting shoved in your mouth. Here you were, with a dick fucking your cunt and another one fucking your throat. “Shit you love that don’t you doll? Being fucked by both of our cocks.” Eren groaned as you moaned repeatedly on his dick. Levi increased his pace and fucked you relentlessly. Levi grunted and hit you harder with each thrust. “Tell me how good you feel, princess. Oh, wait. Your mouth is occupied.” Levi chuckled as he saw Eren fucking your throat and tears were brimming your eyes.
“I-I don’t think I can last any l-longer.” Eren inhaled grabbing your hair roughly. Levi rubbed your clit and pressed against your back while fucking you. “Make Yeager cum, love.” Following his orders, you suck one last time making Eren spill his cum down your throat and overflow your mouth. “You’re so perfect.” Eren laid down on the bed catching his breath. Knowing that Eren was watching you getting utterly destroyed lit a fire inside you.
“Looks like our session is coming to an end (Y/N). Y-You really are amazing.” Levi’s voice faltered as he felt himself reaching his peak as well and yours. “Cum for me princess.” He murmured in your ear. “Do it doll, don’t disobey your captain,” Eren said slyly as you gasped for air. With a certain thrust, you felt yourself cum. Levi gasped as you tightened around him and he pulled out spilling on your back. He rolled over and placed you in between him and Eren. “So what now?” Eren asked getting a blanket and covering the three of you. “We should shower, but I think someone’s a little too tired right now.” Levi smiled gently laying his head on your bare shoulder. “We can take a nap first.” Eren kissed your forehead and let himself fall asleep.
Your eyes shot open at the noise of someone knocking on the door. “Come in...” You said groggily, forgetting about the two naked men sleeping next to you. “Hey (Y/N)-! HOLY SHIT.” Hange walked in and yelled, blood trickling down their nose. “What’s the matter...?” You yawned and looked at your surroundings. Then to the men next to you. “OH MY GOD.” You gasped remembering everything that had happened. Hange chuckled deviously and pulled out a notebook. “Why do you have a notebook!?” Your face goes red as you try covering yourself up. “I need to take notes for my story of course!!” They giggled and danced around tried to imagine what exactly went down here. “Hange. Go away.” Levi threw a pillow at them making Hange shriek and run away closing the door behind them. “I’m gonna go take a shower.” You said getting up and falling to the ground immediately. Levi helped you up and took you to the restroom.
The next day, everyone forgot about your love triangle dilemma and believed that you dumped both of them. Except for four people. You, Levi, and Eren of course. But also the devious commander Hange Zoe. Every day you had to put up with Eren constantly being protective of you and always using the excuse “Captain’s orders!” Every time you would make eye contact with Levi he would wink and flashes of that day filled your mind. You were now stuck with two horny-ass men, repeats of that day happened often. Not that you were complaining.