Actions

Work Header

Not Closed

Summary:

Buffy saw Spike die in Sunnydale. Wolfram & Hart brought him back.

Now Buffy is in Rome rebuilding the Council, and Spike is inside the law firm as its most dangerous loose end — and the Council’s most compromised spy. Every message he sends could save a Slayer or spring a trap. Every secret W&H keeps points back to contracts, claims, prophecy, and a file marked Pratt.

Post-“Chosen” / AtS Season 5 AU. Love is not the problem. Trust is.

Chapter Text

London did not know how to be a Hellmouth.

It had fog instead of dust, rain instead of ash, and old buildings that leaned into one another like they were sharing secrets. It had traffic moving on the wrong side of the road, policemen who did not look twice at teenage girls carrying antique weapons in violin cases, and tea in every room as if tea were an answer to apocalypse.

It was not Sunnydale.

That was the problem.

Buffy stood in the middle of the Council's temporary operations room — formerly a dining room, possibly still haunted by one — and watched three junior Watchers argue over a fax machine. A fax machine. The world had nearly ended, every Potential Slayer on Earth had become considerably less potential, and somehow the ancient order charged with guiding the Chosen One still believed in paper jams.

"Hit it," Rona suggested from the doorway.

A Watcher in tweed — actual tweed, like he had been issued it with his first monocle — looked offended. "That would not be advisable."

"It works on vending machines."

"It is not a vending machine."

"It is eating paper and refusing to give us what we paid for."

Buffy closed her eyes.

Somewhere upstairs, a newly called Slayer was crying because she had broken a bathroom sink by turning the tap too hard. Somewhere downstairs, Giles was in a meeting with people who had survived the destruction of the old Council and seemed determined to prove that the First Evil had missed a few necessary targets. Somewhere in the temporary flat she shared with Dawn, all of their belongings fit into two suitcases, a duffel, and one cardboard box labelled SUNNYDALE, which had seemed funny for about half a second and then had not.

Her city was gone.

Her house was gone.

Her mother's house. The porch. The kitchen island. The stairs she had been thrown down more than once. The basement where Spike had slept, chained, sulking, useful, maddening, there.

No.

The basement where they had stored weapons.

The fax machine made a strangled noise.

Buffy opened her eyes. "Rona."

"Yeah?"

"Hit it."

The tweed Watcher made a small sound of pain.

Rona grinned and smacked the side of the machine. The fax spat out three pages and went quiet, apparently cowed by the new world order.

"There," Buffy said. "Diplomacy."

"Buffy."

Giles stood in the doorway, glasses in hand, looking tired enough to be transparent. He had acquired a new cut on his forehead at some point since breakfast, probably from a falling box of ancient prophecies or a conversation with the finance committee.

He looked at the fax machine, then at Rona, then at Buffy.

"I see we're modernising."

"Violently," Buffy said. "It's very us."

"Could I have a word?"

That meant bad news. Giles had many tones now. There was the gentle one for grieving girls, the clipped one for surviving Watchers, the careful one for Willow, the almost-normal one for Xander over the phone when neither of them mentioned Anya. This was the one for money.

Buffy followed him out into the hall.

The house they were using had belonged to some Council functionary's aunt or great-aunt or possibly one of those women who kept cats and curses in equal number. It was not headquarters. Headquarters had exploded. This was a stopgap full of boxes, borrowed desks, and people pretending not to be afraid.

Giles led her into what had become his office. There were stacks of ledgers on the desk, several old keys, two laptops, a sword in the umbrella stand, and a cup of tea gone grey at the top.

Buffy looked at the ledgers. "If one of those says I owe library fines from 1998, I'm declaring independence."

"You are not in trouble."

"That's never where these talks end."

He sat. He did not ask her to, which meant he knew better. "The Council's remaining assets are considerable."

"Good. Considerable sounds good. I like considerable."

"They are also complicated."

"And there it is."

"Properties, trusts, restricted funds, private donations, investments, emergency reserves, accounts maintained under names that may or may not be legal entities, and a number of income streams whose ethical status is, at best, historical."

Buffy leaned against a bookcase. "Translation?"

"The old Council was wealthy. It was also old, secretive, and occasionally appalling."

"Occasionally?"

Giles removed his glasses and cleaned them, which was British for yes, frequently. "One practice, in particular, may concern you."

"Just one? That's restraint."

"For generations the Council redirected funds obtained by demons through illegal or predatory means."

Buffy stared at him. "Redirected."

"Yes."

"Is that Watcher for stole?"

"In some cases, confiscated. In others, intercepted. In still others..." He hesitated.

"Stole."

"Recovered," Giles said, with the expression of a man who disliked the word even as he used it.

Buffy folded her arms. "Demons robbed people. The Council robbed demons. Everybody wore nicer shoes."

"It was justified on the grounds that demon crimes could not be prosecuted through ordinary human legal systems, and the funds were used to support the Slayer's mission."

"The Slayer's mission," Buffy repeated. "Not the Slayer."

Giles winced.

It was small. It was enough.

Something hot and old moved in Buffy's chest. She had been poor in a house full of Potentials while the Council had had emergency reserves and hidden accounts and enough money to buy tweed by the acre. She had worked fast food. She had worried about plumbing. She had come home bruised and still had bills on the counter. Her mother had died and left her a mortgage. The Council had watched girls die for centuries and called it sacred duty, and somewhere in London men had been putting demon money into ledgers.

"You paid Watchers," she said.

"Yes."

"Before they exploded, I mean."

"Yes."

"Good salaries?"

Giles was silent.

Buffy laughed once. It came out sharp and ugly. "Of course. Of course you did. Because the sacred calling comes with dental if you get to stand next to the girl instead of be the girl."

"Buffy—"

"No. We're doing this now." She pushed away from the bookcase. "Every Slayer gets paid. Every one we find. Food, housing, training, medical, school if they want it, money that is theirs. Not a stipend handed over to their Watcher. Theirs."

"I agree."

That stopped her for half a beat.

Giles looked up at her. "I do. Completely."

"You do."

"Yes."

"Oh." Buffy had been prepared to fight. She was good at prepared to fight. "Well. Good."

"There are details to settle."

"There are always details. Details are where old British men hide the knives."

He accepted that without flinching, which made her feel worse. "There is also the matter of back payment."

Buffy's anger, which had been looking for a wall, found a door instead.

"Back payment," she said.

"For Faith, certainly. For you, obviously. Arguably for Kendra's estate, if such a thing can be located. There will be questions of precedent—"

"Pay me."

Giles blinked. "I beg your pardon?"

"You said back payment. Pay me."

"I intended to propose a structure—"

"No. You intended to discuss a structure. Then form a committee. Then have the committee discover moral complexity in the wild. Then maybe, if we're all very patient, a girl with superpowers and no home gets a cheque when she's thirty."

"That is not fair."

"Neither was being sixteen and dying for free."

His face changed. Not much. Enough.

Buffy heard herself breathing. She knew she was being cruel. She knew Giles was not the Council, not entirely, not anymore. She knew he had been fired for loving her too much and had come back with borrowed magic and grief in his pockets.

She knew all of it.

She also knew that her house had been swallowed by the earth.

"I want what I'm owed," she said, quieter.

Giles looked at her for a long moment. Then he nodded.

"All right."

It should have felt like victory.

It did not.


She found William Pratt by accident, except she knew that was a lie even while she was doing it.

The records room was in the basement because of course it was. Watchers apparently believed knowledge improved with damp. The surviving files had been dragged out of vaults, annexes, private houses, bank boxes, and one monastery in Kent. Some were smoke-damaged. Some were handwritten. Some had little tags that said things like VAMPIRIC LINEAGES: AURELIUS, CROSS-REFERENCE WITH SCOURGE OF EUROPE, SEE ALSO: DARLA, DRUSILLA.

Buffy stood in front of that box for a very long time.

Then she took it down.

She told herself she was checking for anything about the amulet. Angel had brought it from Wolfram & Hart, and Spike had worn it, and there had to be something, somewhere, in all this dead paper. Something useful. Something tactical. Something that was not the shape of his hand catching fire.

The file on Spike was thick, which would have pleased him in the worst possible way. There were sketches. Sightings. Reports. Names. William the Bloody, with underlined warnings about railway spikes and poetry, because the universe had a sense of humour and mostly used it for injuries.

There was a note from 1880.

William Pratt. Born London, 1852. Family address listed.

Buffy read the address twice.

Then again.

She had known, technically, that Spike had been human. It was a fact. Vampires came from people. Angel had been Liam. Drusilla had been a girl before she became a nightmare. Spike had been William before he had been Spike.

But knowing was different from seeing his name in brown ink, neat and domestic, beside a London address.

William Pratt.

Not a thug. Not born in an alley with a cigarette and a sneer. Not the swaggering lie he had built so carefully that even he sometimes seemed to believe it.

Comfortable, the file suggested. Educated. Respectable family. Some property. Mother deceased later, circumstances uncertain. Turned by Drusilla.

Buffy shut the file.

Then opened it again.

The file had been updated more than once by Watchers with an unhealthy interest in vampire origins: sale records, inheritance notes, later owners, the kind of dead-paper trail only the Council would keep for a man who had stopped being legally alive in 1880.

The house was not far, not really. London made everything feel both ancient and inconvenient, but the address was reachable by Tube and a long walk in boots not meant for rain.

She went the next morning without telling anyone.

It was narrower than she expected, taller, with tired brick and black railings and windows filmed with grime. The houses on either side had been scrubbed up and polished into money. William's house had not. Its paint peeled. Its front steps were cracked. A board covered one basement window. Weeds had staged a hostile takeover in the tiny front area.

There was a FOR SALE sign bolted to the railings.

Buffy stood on the pavement while London moved around her.

Once, this had been a nice house.

She could see it if she tried. Not grand, not mansion nice. But good. Solid. A family house. Rooms with fireplaces. Stairs polished by feet. A place where a man could grow up soft enough to write bad poetry and be hurt when people laughed.

Spike would have hated that she knew.

That was the first thing that made her smile.

The estate agent was a brisk woman in a navy coat who had opinions about "period features" and "significant modernisation" and "excellent bones," which seemed to mean the house was not actively falling into the sewer. The roof needed work. The wiring needed replacing. The kitchen was a crime. There was damp in one wall but no major structural damage, apparently, as if that were a compliment.

"It would be quite beautiful restored," the agent said, with the cautious optimism of someone who did not intend to pay for restoration.

Buffy stood in a room with cracked plaster and a marble fireplace under a sheet of dust. Light came through tall windows and lay across the floorboards in pale rectangles.

She imagined Dawn doing homework at a table. Willow with tea. Xander complaining about British hardware stores. Giles pretending not to be pleased by shelves. Slayers coming in and out until the place was noisy and scuffed and alive.

That was later. Maybe. Half a year at best before anyone could live here, probably longer if the plumbing had opinions.

For now it was empty.

For now it was his.

No. It had been William's. Spike would have mocked the curtains and stolen the silver.

Buffy put a hand on the mantel.

She did not cry.

"I'll make an offer," she said.

The agent brightened. "Wonderful. I should warn you there has been some interest—"

"Full asking," Buffy said.

The agent's smile changed. Not much, but enough for Buffy to understand that full asking meant something different when it came without mortgage questions. Giles had called the first payment provisional, which was Watcher for large enough to frighten her and not large enough to settle the argument. Back pay, hardship compensation, emergency disbursement — the words kept changing. The number had not. It sat in an account with her name on it, strange and heavy and already half-spent in her head.

It was not sensible.

It was not Council property. It would not be a headquarters. It would not house girls next week, or Dawn tomorrow, or anyone until vast amounts of money had been thrown into the damp, cracked mouth of it.

It was hers.

She had earned that, she told herself.

By dying. By saving the world. By losing every place she had ever belonged. By being the girl instead of the man with the salary. By going home every night to a house with broken windows and blood in the bathroom and people asking what came next.

She had earned something.

The thought was true.

That was what made it dangerous.


The demon was not buying girls.

That was the first thing it said, which made Buffy immediately want to kick it through the table.

"I admire the legal strategy," she said. "Usually people wait until after I accuse them before they start sounding guilty."

The room had once been private, expensive, and full of men who thought old wood made bad decisions look respectable. Now it smelled of wine, candle wax, and panic. Willow stood by the door with one hand raised, holding the ward over the exits. Kennedy covered the back window. Two junior Watchers hovered in the corridor, trying to look useful and not terrified.

The demon at the table was thin and grey, with long fingers, no visible mouth, and a silk waistcoat that probably cost more than Buffy's entire life before the words back payment.

Its voice came from a brass speaking-tube set into the tabletop.

"I facilitate introductions."

Buffy looked at the papers spread between them. "Between newly called Slayers and people who think 'facilitate' sounds better than 'sell.'"

"No one was sold."

"That sentence has footnotes."

Willow moved closer, careful not to touch the papers. "There are names."

"Girls?" Buffy asked.

"Families. Addresses. Schools. Some birth dates. Some are partial."

Kennedy's crossbow shifted.

The demon folded its hands. "Information has value. That is hardly a demonic innovation."

"You're tracking them," Buffy said.

"I am collating unusual incident reports, medical anomalies, police irregularities, private testimony—"

Buffy put one hand on the table.

The demon stopped.

"Try again."

For a moment, there was only the hum of Willow's ward.

"People are frightened," it said at last. "Girls wake with strength. They break things. Families seek explanations. Doctors seek confidentiality. Former Watchers seek relevance. Everyone asks questions. Everyone tells someone."

"And you make sure the right monsters hear."

"I make sure interested parties are aware of opportunities."

Kennedy made a sound under her breath.

Buffy picked up one page by the corner. There were columns.

Name. Age. Location. Manifestation. Household stability. Prior supernatural exposure.

Estimated recoverability.

She stared at the last word until it stopped meaning anything.

"What does recoverability mean?"

The demon did not answer.

Buffy smiled.

It answered.

"Likelihood that the subject may be removed from current guardianship with minimal public disturbance."

Willow went very still.

Not buying girls. No. That would have been too simple. Too easy to kill.

This was fear made into paperwork. A frightened mother told a doctor. A neighbour called someone who knew someone. By the time the girl had broken her second door handle, she had become a line in a ledger.

Buffy set the page down carefully.

"You're going to give us every list," she said. "Every copy. Every name you sold them to."

"I am bound by client confidentiality."

Kennedy actually laughed.

The demon placed a small ivory card on the table. "I am also indemnified."

There it was. Not the full sigil. Something subtler: three abstract marks worked into the border, almost decoration, almost legalese.

Willow inhaled.

Buffy heard it. "What?"

"I've seen a version of that."

"Where?"

"Angel," Willow said. "The law firm. Wolfram and Hart."

The demon's fingers relaxed. Not relief. Recognition.

Buffy looked at the card. "You work for them?"

"No."

"Careful. My friend is holding the exits shut with her brain."

"I do not work for them. They guarantee certain instruments. Witness certain transfers. Provide standing where standing would otherwise be disputed."

"That is a lot of words for yes."

"It is a precise distinction."

The demon sounded almost proud.

Then it slapped one hand onto the table.

The papers burst into green flame.

Willow shouted something sharp and old. The fire froze above the pages, flickering in place without burning. Kennedy fired. The bolt took the demon in the shoulder just as Buffy vaulted the table and drove it back into the wall.

"Names," Buffy said.

"I cannot—"

She hit it against the plaster.

"Names."

Its smooth face turned toward the ivory card.

For the first time, Buffy understood that it was afraid.

Not of her.

Or not only of her.

"You opened all the cages," it whispered through the brass tube, though the tube was still on the table. "One Slayer was manageable. Many Slayers are a market. You gave power to girls and no walls around them. No papers. No claims. No recognised guardianship."

Buffy's grip tightened.

The broken sink upstairs. The crying girl. Rona laughing at the fax machine. Dawn's suitcase still unpacked. A house in London with cracked plaster and good bones.

Girls everywhere, waking up dangerous and unprotected.

"No," Buffy said. "We made them strong."

The demon went silent.

"The rest is on people like you."

This time, when she asked, it gave names.

Not all of them. Some were probably lies. Some were probably bait. Some were aliases the surviving Council would argue over for weeks. But it gave enough.

When they finally left the club, London was raining again.

Willow held the ivory card wrapped in a scarf. Kennedy's jaw was tight. Behind them, the Watchers carried the sealed papers as if they might start screaming.

"Wolfram and Hart," Willow said.

"Angel's law firm," Kennedy said.

Buffy did not answer.

She knew the outline. Angel had taken over Wolfram & Hart's Los Angeles branch. He had not called to explain it properly. There had been messages, careful ones, passed through Giles and Willow and people in Los Angeles who apparently thought second-hand reassurance was a substitute for one impossible conversation. Angel was using their resources. Angel was changing things from inside. Angel had reasons. Sometimes the reasons were even good.

But demons in London were using the firm's marks on papers that turned frightened girls into recoverable subjects.

Not owned.

Not yet.

That was almost worse.

Buffy looked at the wrapped card.

Angel, what did you do?


"You bought a house."

Dawn said it from the doorway of their temporary room, arms folded, voice flat in the way that meant she had been building toward not-flat for some time.

Buffy looked up from the stack of papers on her bed. "Hello to you too."

"You bought a house."

"Technically I made an offer."

"Technically I found the envelope from the estate agent because you stuffed it under your jumper like a criminal and then forgot laundry exists."

Buffy glanced at the chair.

The envelope was gone.

Traitor envelope.

Dawn stepped inside and shut the door. Their room was small, with two narrow beds, one wardrobe, and a view of a brick wall. Dawn's suitcase was open on the floor. Buffy's clothes were mostly still in hers because unpacking felt too much like believing this was where they lived.

"You bought a house," Dawn said again, and this time her voice cracked at the edge. "Here. In London. A house we can't even live in."

"It needs work."

"It needs a roof, Buffy."

"It has a roof."

"It has roof-adjacent optimism."

Buffy put the papers aside. "Dawn—"

"No, don't 'Dawn' me. We're living in weird Council dorm land with girls everywhere and Watchers whispering and someone keeps using my shampoo even though I wrote DAWN on it in permanent marker, and you bought a house that won't be ready for six months. At best. That's what the report says. Half a year before it's even habitable."

"I know."

"Then why?"

Buffy looked at her sister.

Dawn's anger was not just anger. Buffy should have seen that earlier. It was fear in a coat. It was the same fear Buffy felt every morning when she woke up and did not know which ceiling she was under.

They had lost the same house.

Not in the same way, because no two people ever lost the same thing exactly. Dawn had lost the place Joyce had made for them. Buffy had lost that too, and something else layered under it, something she had not let herself touch.

"I took the money as back pay," Buffy said.

Dawn stared. "That is so not the question."

"It's part of the question."

"No, it's the part where you make it sound like a Council memo so I forget to be mad."

Buffy almost smiled. Almost.

"Giles knows," she said. "About the money. It wasn't sneaky stealing. More like angry accounting."

"Buffy."

"I know." The words came out too fast. "I know it's not fair. Or it's fair, but only if it's fair for everyone, and it can't be, not all at once. There are so many girls. More every day. And I stood there yelling about what I was owed, and I was right, and then I hated being right because right still looked a lot like taking."

Dawn's face softened, but only a little. "So why that house?"

Buffy picked at the edge of one paper until it bent.

There were many answers. The good bones. The price, which was not good but was survivable. The possible future. The fact that Slayers always ended up in her living room anyway, so someday it would probably become a half-headquarters no matter what she called it.

She could say all of that.

Dawn would hear the lie inside it.

"It was William's," Buffy said.

Dawn blinked. "William?"

"William Pratt. Spike."

For a moment there was only London rain against the window.

"Oh," Dawn said.

Buffy nodded, staring at her hands. "I found it in the records. I wasn't looking. Except I was. I wanted to know... I don't know what I wanted to know. Something. Anything. The Council had files. Of course they had files. And there was an address."

"So you went."

"Yeah."

"What's it like?"

"Terrible." Buffy let out a breath that was almost a laugh. "Damp. Expensive. The kitchen is where kitchens go after being bad in life. There might be rats with legal tenancy. But it used to be nice. You can tell. It has..." She searched for the estate agent's phrase and found it unwillingly. "Good bones."

Dawn sat on the edge of her own bed.

"He was rich?"

"Comfortable. I think." Buffy swallowed. "Not what he pretended. Not some street guy with fists and attitude. He had a house. A family. Fireplaces. Probably horrible curtains."

"Bad poetry."

"Definitely bad poetry."

Dawn looked down at her hands. "He would hate that you know."

"I know."

"That's kind of nice."

"Yeah."

The silence changed. It did not become easy. Easy was gone with Sunnydale, with Joyce, with a hundred normal things that had never really been normal but had been theirs.

Dawn wiped at her face quickly, like she was annoyed at her own eyes.

"I miss our house," she said.

Buffy's throat closed.

"I know."

"No, I mean, I miss stupid stuff. The microwave that sparked if you put popcorn in for too long. The banister that was always loose because people kept getting thrown into it. Mom's plates. Even the basement, which was objectively gross."

Buffy looked away.

Dawn noticed. Of course she noticed.

"I miss him too," Dawn said.

Buffy did not answer.

"He was awful sometimes," Dawn added, because she was Dawn and grief did not make her less honest. "And he hurt you. And he hurt me. And I know all that. But he also stayed. When people didn't."

Buffy pressed her palms together until her fingers hurt.

"He burned," she said.

It was the first time she had said anything that close to it.

Dawn moved from her bed to Buffy's. Not dramatically. Just crossed the small strip of ugly carpet and sat beside her.

Buffy did not lean on her. Not at first.

"I don't know what the house is," Buffy said. "It's not ours. It's not Sunnydale. It's not a headquarters. It's not even liveable. I just saw it and thought... once, he had somewhere. Before everything. Before blood and leather and all the stupid things he made himself into. He had somewhere."

"And you wanted somewhere too."

Buffy nodded.

Dawn put her shoulder against Buffy's.

For once, Buffy let the weight stay.

After a while Dawn said, "Six months is still ridiculous."

"I know."

"And if we move in and there are rats, I get the biggest room."

"If there are rats, the rats get the biggest room. They have seniority."

Dawn made a small sound. Not quite a laugh. Close enough.

Buffy looked at the rain blurring the window and tried to imagine the house with lights on, with Dawn's books on a table, with Willow's herbs in the kitchen, with Xander complaining over a crackly international call that British walls were made of spite, with girls coming in from the cold and not being alone.

Not replacing.

Never replacing.

But maybe someday another place.

Maybe someday home.

On the desk, under the estate agent's stolen envelope and the repair estimate and the first ugly list of costs, the copied page from the demon ledger waited.

Wolf. Ram. Hart.

Buffy did not look at it.

Not yet.

For one minute, she let herself sit beside her sister and grieve the dead.

All of them.