Chapter Text
TW//Self-Harm, Phone Sex, daddy kink
Dean Winchester and his younger brother Sam, learned that they were getting a new neighbor. The boy’s father, John Winchester, recommended that they go bring a pie over to them. “Okay dad, we will,” Dean said. “And watch after Sammy” John said; “Sam” Sam signed to his dad. He hated when anyone called him ‘Sammy’, that was all about to change as soon as he met his neighbor. Sam was 16 and had selective mutism; because he had a stuttering problem and he elongated the letter ‘S’. Dean on the other hand was 20 and slightly talkative. He even learned sign language just to talk to his brother in public. “I’ll make sure Sam here doesn’t get into any trouble” Dean chuckled while Sam punched him in the shoulder. “And Sam, you watch over Dean” John told Sam, Sam just gave him a thumbs up. “Alright, I’ll see you boys next week, there's $50 on the desk for food. Be Safe.” John said while walking out the door. Once John drove away in the Impala, Sam went back to his room to finish reading his book. Where Dean did what he does best, make pie. Once the Pie was finished, “SAM!” Dean shouted for Sam to get him downstairs. Sam gladly finished his book so he went downstairs to see what Dean wanted. “What Dean?” Sam signed. “We’re delivering the pie now, let’s go” Dean said while carrying the pie out the door with Sam behind him. “Why do I have to go with you?” Sam asked while signing. “Because, there might be someone your age there” Dean teased his brother. “You’re an asshole Dean.” Sam signed to Dean. Sam had a specific sign for Dean, it was the sign for squirrel but he used ‘D’ instead of using two fingers to sign it. “Love you too Sam” Dean said while messing up Sam’s totally perfect hair and walked over to the house across from theirs. It was 2 stories and had multiple windows across the top, basically saying there were multiple rooms. So they thought they didn’t make enough pie for them. “I think we should go back and make another pie-” Dean said. “Let’s just go Dean, we’ll be okay” Sam signed. “But there might not be enough pie-'' Dean mumbled, for being the older, more talkative sibling, he sure was shy. “Let’s just go Dean '' Sam signed. They both walked up to the door and Dean rang the doorbell. “I don’t want to do this anymore Sam-” Dean mumbled. “It’s okay Dean '' Sam signed before someone opened the door. “Hm? Oh hello.” Chuck said. “I’m Dean Winchester, this is Sam Winchester, we're your across the street neighbors and we brought you pie” Dean said. “Oh thank you boys, why don’t you come inside and help us eat it?” Chuck asked, and Sam looked at Dean and Dean looked at Sam before looking back at Chuck. “We would love to, maybe we could head back over to our house so we can make a second pie if anyone here wants more pie” Dean smiled. Chuck gave them a thumbs up and they walked over to their house so they could make their second pie. “That tall moose sure has a nice ass~” Gabriel flirted, and it turns out all of Chuck’s kids were watching from the living room window. “Shut up Gabe-” Raphael said, smacking Gabriel in the back of the head. “Ouchie '' Gabe pouted. “All of you stop fighting, and calm down, we’re having guests over” Chuck said. Castiel, the calmest of the bunch Chuck had, was reading a book. Here’s a list of his kids; Lucifer, Raphael, Balthazar, Gabriel, Anna, Uriel, and Castiel. Yes his children have religious names, and yes they live in a mansion. Sam and Dean’s house is a one story place with 3 rooms. Once Sam and Dean got back to the Novak’s with their second pie; they all sat down in the kitchen, and they ate their pie. “Would you boys like to stay here and hang out?” Chuck asked Sam and Dean. The Winchesters looked at each other then back at Chuck “Yeah sure” Dean said for the both of them. So everyone but Chuck sat down in the living room, and talked to each other. “Why doesn’t moose here talk?” Gabe asked Dean, getting a smack in the back of the head by Raphael again. Sam and Dean looked at each other once again, Sam giving Dean an ‘it’s okay, you can tell them’ look. “Alright, roundup Novak’s, today you’re going to learn about Sam’s selective mutism here” Dean said. “It can be selective? I thought people were born mute-'' Gabe said, almost getting smacked in the head by Raph again but Gabe caught his hand “Hit me again and you won’t live next morning.” Gabe said angrily, looking back at Dean ``Please continue Dean.” None of the Novak’s have seen Gabriel angry but they’ve heard him angry. “Yeah, it can be selective, Sam’s reason he went mute was because of his speech problems' ' Dean said, looking at Sam. “I can teach all of you sign language” Sam signed while Dean translated for him. “Yes please!” Gabe said jumping up because he was excited to talk to the hot moose man. “Well someones excited” Sam quietly chuckled, while Dean translated for him. Gabe blushed because he didn’t want to embarrass himself like that in front of his brothers who would definitely make fun of him if they knew that Gabe liked Sam. “Awwwww, someone has a little crushhhhhh~” Luci teased. “No!” Gabriel covered his face and ran upstairs to his room. Sam followed him, sliding a note under Gabes door ‘Hey, it’s Sam. Are you okay?’ He wrote. Not getting a response until Gabe opened the door “No, and I’ll tell you about it, I pretty much talk so much that I’ll basically talk for you Sam-'' Gabe held his hand out to Sam, who was sitting on the floor. Sam held his hand and he was brought up and into Gabe’s room. “So, I came out to my brothers the week before we got here and they’ve been teasing me about finding a boyfriend here. And I really think you’re a sweet guy Sam, I really really do. I just get so blushy near you- and now you’re in my roommm-'' Gabe mumbled “I’m sorry for bothering you Samford- And we just started to get to know each other and be glad that you don’t have siblings that make fun of your sexuality.” Sam didn’t know what to do so he held Gabe's face, causing Gabe to smile. “Sammmmm-” Gabe whined. “Your ssssmile Gabe” Sam spoke; and Gabe's jaw dropped, Sam’s voice was so angelic “You talked! I promise, I won’t tell anyone that you chose to speak to me” Gabe jump-hugged Sam. Sam hugged Gabe back. “Please don’t ignore me after what just happened, please Samford” Gabe nuzzled into Sam’s neck. “I won- I won’t ignore or forget you Gabe, I prom- promisssse” Sam said, holding Gabe closer to him. “Thanks Moose,” Gabe said, cuddling Sam.
~Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey Stuff to the afternoon of Halloween, 1 month after the Novak’s arrived in Kansas~
Sam and Dean were in their house, packing to move to Cali. They told the Novak’s that morning, and Gabe has been in a depression since. Once Sam and Dean were done packing, they went to the Novak’s for their final goodbye. “Where’s Gabe?” Sam signed, Cas looked at him “He’s in his room Sam” Cas told him. Sam immediately ran up to his room “Gabe, pleassse let me in '' Sam whispered. He heard Gabe get up and open the door. “What is it Sammy-?'' Gabe asked, dry tears on his face. “I really want to ssstay, I ssswear, I wissh I had a choiccce to ssstay Gabe” Sam wiped Gabe’s tears. “I know, Sam, I know. And it’s hard to let you go, and what if you forget me even though you promised not to.” Gabe sniffled. “Gabe, I promissse, I will never forget you” Sam kissed Gabe’s forehead. “Sam! Come on! We can’t keep dad waiting in the car!” Dean yelled for Sam from downstairs. “I’ll remember you Gabe, I promissse” Sam said, kissing Gabe’s forehead and leaving. “I love you Samford-” Gabe mumbled quietly.
~More Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey sequences to 10 years later~
Sam was in College at Stanford, he had a girlfriend named Jessica. And he forgot how Gabe looked. He remembered how close he and Gabe were and how badly he crushed on him as kids; Gabe was the first person Sam ever talked to. But now Sam is talking, he’s not mute anymore cause he’s not stuttering much anymore. But when Gabe and Cas were visiting, he was so excited to see Gabe after 10 years. Dean invited all of them to a horror movie marathon at his house. The marathon was all Sam could think about during classes. “Sammy? You okay hun?” Jess asked, kissing Sam on the cheek. “Yeah, yeah I'm okay Jess, I just spaced out” Sam smiled. She hugged him “Alright Sammy, I’m going to go get coffee, Love you Samford” Jess said walking away. “You know only Gabe calls me Samford-” Sam said. Jess waved her hand like ‘I know, I know’. Sam looked at his phone, his lock screen wallpaper was a photo of him and Jess.
Dean messaged him, saying ‘Hey kid, I’m gonna be out with Cas for a bit, you have my spare key so you can just walk in yk. I don’t have a word on Gabe tho’.
Sam replied ‘Got it, can Jess come? I want her to meet Gabe’ .
Dean answered ‘Sam, you know this is a guys night, we haven’t seen Cas and Gabe in awhile so I’d rather not bring your girlfriend just yet’ .
Jess walked up to Sam “I’m back Sammy” Jess said, setting Sam’s coffee next to him. “Hey Jess” Sam kissed her cheek. “You okay?” Jess asked. “Yeah, I’m just tired,” Sam said, drinking his coffee. “Alright hun, you ready to leave?” Jess said, putting Sam’s things in his bag. “Yeah, I’m ready,” Sam said, getting up. The two walked out, laughing and holding hands. Till, they ran into this boy, he was about 5 '7, his hair going to his shoulders and sideburns, looking at Sam. “Hey, Samford,” the boy said. Sam thought he looked familiar but couldn’t tell. “I’m sorry, who are you?” Sam asked. “It’s Gabe, Novak. We used to be across the street neighbors in Kansas.” Gabe said. “Sorry, but my friend should be at my brother's house, and not here,” Sam said, walking away with Jess. “I made up the nickname Samford for you, I even made you your own sign name Sammy” Gabe said. “Sammy is a chubby 12 year old, it’s Sam.” Sam glared at Gabe “Now I have to get home, goodbye now.” Sam walked away, linking arms with Jess. Gabe sniffled, walking the opposite way from the happy couple, texting cas
‘Hey Cas, I’m gonna go find a train home’ Gabe texted Cas.
Gabe had his headphones in his ears, and he waited a few minutes for Cas to respond ‘what? Why?’ Cas texted back
‘Sam forgot what I looked like’ Gabe responded.
‘Oh shit.’ Cas replied.
‘Yeah, tell D-man I’ll see him when he and Sam visit us in Kansas’ Gabe texted. He was finally at the bus stop, then he was gonna take a few buses and trains to Kansas. It’d take him at least 2 days for him to get to Kansas. So he bought his tickets, and went on his bus.
~More Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey sequences to 8 hours later~
Sam was just getting to Dean's house. He was really excited to see Gabe after 10 years of being apart. Once he walked in, he was hoping to be greeted by Gabriel but he was greeted by Cas, handing Sam what looked to be one of Gabe’s hoodies. “Hm? Where’s Gabe?” Sam asked. Dean and Cas looked at each other then at Sam. “He went home early, he got home sick, he really wanted to see you Sam so he left you this” Cas said, Gabe had left Sam an oversized hoodie, even on Sam it’s oversized, and lollipops. Sam’s heart crushed and he went to his room to cry. “Maybe that was Gabe earlier-” Sam mumbled into the hoodie; how he hurt after he knew he just hurt his childhood best friend. “Sam? You okay there?” Dean asked. Sam was crying into the hoodie “mmhmm” Sam mumbled. “Alright, if you need anything Sammy, me and Cas are going to be in the living room” Dean said, before walking away from Sam’s door. Sam’s heart hurt so much he didn’t correct Dean when he called him Sammy. Sam looked at the hoodie then to a photo next to his bed, it was a photo of him and Gabe, Gabe kissing Sam on the cheek and Sam blushing very brightly, in one of Sam’s giant jackets. “I’m so sorry Gabriel, I’m so so sorry” Sam mumbled, starting to cry. “Please don’t hate me forever Gabe- I didn’t mean to forget your face, it’s just been ten years since I last saw you and so I forgot your face” Sam sobbed into the hoodie, “I’m so fucking sorry Gabe.” Sam slid the hoodie on, sniffling. Sam lifted up his left sleeve, looking at his wrist. “Don’t do it Sam- Gabes not here to help you Sam- Please don’t do it-” Sam told himself, reaching to his drawer, opening it slowly. “Don’t.” Sam mumbled, grabbing his knife from the drawer, sliding over to his wrist. “Please don’t do it Sammy- what would Gabe say?” Sam said, slowly gliding the blade across his wrist, wincing in the process. Dean heard him wince, causing him to get up and go to Sam’s room. Sam cut deeper and faster; not noticing his brother stormed into his room. “Sam!” Dean shouted, causing Sam to stop and look up at him. Dean walked over to Sam, taking the knife and putting it in between his pants waistband and boxers waistband. “Kid, you know I only take your knife cause I love you, and want you safe, right?” Dean asked. Sam nodded, “Yeah, I know, and I love you too.” Sam reached into his drawer again and grabbed bandages. “Do you have any more weapons that will hurt you Sammy?” Dean asked, looking underthings. “Mmhmm” Sam wrapped his wrist up, grabbing the gun under his pillow, mattress, and his bed. He also pulled out a few knives from his drawer, and closet. “God, we have wayyyyy too many weapons; anywho me and Cas are going out for dinner, see you later kiddo” Dean chuckled, walking out to put the weapons away and leave with Cas. Sam looked at his phone and grabbed it, opened his text messages, and texted Gabe.
‘Hey Gabe, um, I’m sorry for earlier, but I’m going to try to convince Dean to let us move back to kansas. And I kinda cut again- it’s okay if you ignore me but I really wanted to tell you what I did.” Sam texted Gabe, watching the sent go to read; then he got a call from Gabe. He answered.
‘Sam?’ Gabe asked, it sounded busy, he was probably at a train station.
‘Gabe, I didn’t think you’d call- Sorry for bothering you Gabe, I’m re-really sorry-’ Sam apologized, sniffling.
‘Sammy, I promise you it’s okay.” Gabe reassured him.
‘I forgot what you looked like, I promised you I wouldn’t do that- I’m a horrible friend, I’m a re- really bad friend.’ Sam sobbed.
‘Sammy, stop talking bad about yourself, you’re my best friend and it’s been 10 years and we’re older so our faces have changed, except for yours. You still have your stupid little dimples, I would go back but I’m out in L.A. and I have a train to catch to get to Phoenix. But I will immediately call you whenever I get there. I promise.’ Gabe said.
‘Okay, I probably won’t be able to sleep with the pain from my wrist,’ Sam chuckled, earning a groan from Gabe.
‘Samford, go clean the cuts, I know you cut deep’ Gabe said sternly.
‘But Gabeeeee’ Sam whined.
‘Now Sam.’ Gabe groaned, a tent started to form in Sam’s pants.
‘Now I can’t get up- I have to deal with…something; I’ll call you when I'm done..’ Sam whined again.
‘Alright, see ya Sammy’ Gabe said.
‘Bye Gabe’ and Sam hung up, at least he thought he did.
Sam whined, getting up from his bed, adjusting his dick with his growing boner. He made a small whimper; “fuck..” Sam mumbled. He opened a drawer, pulling out a purple dildo, his favorite color. He also pulled out lube, mumbling out. “God dammit Sam, you promised yourself you’d never do this whenever you wanted him in you-.” Gabe noticed Sam never really hung up, so he looked around the outside of his room on the train and plugged in his headphones to listen to his little Sammy. Gabe bucked his hips up a bit; letting out a soft groan. Sam heard that, so he looked at his phone ‘Oh fuck- I- I am so so so so sorry Gabe-’ Sam whined.
‘No, don’t be, please continue Sammy, I wanna hear you be a needy little slut for me.’ Gabe teased; unzipping his pants.
‘Gabeeee’ Sam whined out; letting his jeans and boxers drop down to his ankles.
‘I have you Sammy, not physically but I will be here for you. I want to listen to each and every moan from you~’ Gabe chuckled.
Just those words coming from Gabe made Sam moan, nothing in him, nothing prepping him, just simple words. ‘Gabey, I miss you so much’ Sam whined.
‘Shhh, start prepping yourself Sammy, Daddy will be here to listen to you. I know I’m not with you but you can always turn on your camera for Daddy to watch you’ Gabe said, getting his dick out of his pants and boxers.
‘Okay sir’ Sam sat on his bed, grabbing his phone and put it across from him, laying against pillows.
‘You got this Sammy, I know you do’ Gabe said, soothing Sam and making anything Sam was afraid of doing go away. Sam sighed, letting his shoulders drop, and turned on his camera, his face immediately going into a bright red.
‘Hi Gabe-‘ Sam said softly.
‘Daddy.’ Gabe corrected him sternly.
‘Hi Daddy’ Sam blushed brighter.
‘Hi baby, you’re getting really red’ Gabe spoke
‘I know sir’ Sam chuckled
‘Well, start prepping your little hole Sammy’ Gabe said, Gabe knew this was wrong; he knew Sam had a girlfriend but he knew that this would never happen again. So he encouraged it.
‘Yes sir-’ Sam mumbled, putting lube on 3 of his fingers. Still very embarrassed.
‘You got this baby, I believe in you doll’ Gabe said, watching Sam take a few breaths in and a few breaths out. Then Sam slowly slid a finger into himself, letting out a soft and shuttered moan.
‘You got this Sammy, Daddy’s proud of you’ Gabe teases. Sam moaned while he snuck in a second finger.
‘Be gentle with yourself Sammy, don’t give yourself more when you’re not ready for it’ Gabe soothed Sam. While Sam put in the last finger, he took small and soft breathy moans.
‘Can I put in the dildo now Daddy?’ Sam asked, his moans getting louder.
‘No need to ask me Sammy, you can make your decisions yourself baby’ Gabe assured Sam. Sam only nodded; letting the dildo slide into his tight little hole.
Sam started to slowly bounce on the dildo, letting Gabe watch him and whisper sweet nothings to him. Gabe loved watching his Sammy bounce on the dildo; His Sammy. He owned Sam, Sam wasn’t Jess’, Sam was Gabriel’s. Sam would never do this in front of Jess, only Gabe. Sam just wanted Gabe, he wanted to be Gabe’s personal slut. ‘C- cumming gabey-!’ Sam whined.
‘Cum Sammy, cum for me.’ Gabe instructed. Sam jerked himself off fast while bouncing on the dildo, moaning loudly for his Daddy. Then he came all over his phone.
‘Good job Sammy, Daddy’s so proud of you.’ Gabe said proudly, Gabe came on his shirt awhile ago, he just didn’t tell Sam because he wanted to watch Sam finish.
‘Thank you daddy’ Sam said
‘You’re welcome Samshine’ Gabe chuckled, Sam liked that nickname, he really liked that stupid nickname. He liked all of the stupid names Gabe gave him. Then Sam heard a knock on his door, Gabe also heard the knock.
‘I’ll talk to you later, okay Sammybuns?’ Gabe said.
‘Okay, love you,’ Sam said, putting his pants on and wiping off his sweat.
‘Love you too Sammy’ Then Gabe hung up. Sam cleaned off his phone and went to the door; It was Jess, Sam’s girlfriend. “Sammy!!” Jess said, jumping into her boyfriend's arms. “Hey baby, what brings you here?” Sam asked. He knew he was falling out of love with her but he couldn’t bring himself to break up with her. He hated breaking up with people, he’s had like 2 girlfriends and 3 boyfriends. He was the one to break up with all of them because he kept falling out of love and just wanted Gabe in the end. God, he knows he can’t be doing this again, Jess is a sweet girl and he hates her sad. “Danny? You okay?” Jess said, not catching what she said; but Sam did. Sam heard her say ‘Danny’, “Danny?” Sam asked. “Who?” Jess asked, noticing Sam’s sad face. “Are you cheating on me Jess?” Sam asked. “No Sammy! I wouldn’t!” Jess said, getting a call from ‘Danny’ who was labeled as ‘my baby boy’ on her phone. “Who is Danny, Jessica?!” Sam said sternly. “He’s just a friend Sammy!” Jess shouted. “It’s Sam. And we’re done Jessica. I cannot deal with you right now so get out of my house.” Sam spoke. “What? Sammy, please-” Jess begged. “I SAID OUT JESSICA!” Sam shouted, pushing Jess out of the house and slamming the door behind her. Sam was pissed so he texted Gabe on what just happened.
‘I just broke up with Jess’ Sam texted Gabe. And Gabe didn’t answer, normally he would just immediately so Sam thought he was sleeping. Which he was; he was very tired from his actions earlier. So Sam just sat in his room, in the quiet and darkness of his room; slowly falling asleep.
~More Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey sequences to 3 days later~
Sam, Dean, and Cas were at the airport, Dean and Cas were being all lovey and cuddling while Sam texted Gabe on what Dean and Cas were doing. “Hey Sammy; When we get home are we going to start packing to go back to Kansas?” Dean asked. Cas looked shocked like Dean never told him they were moving back. “Wait, you’re coming back to Kansas?” Cas asked excitedly; he jumped onto Dean cause he can’t wait to be with his boyfriend 24/7. “Yeah, I can’t wait to surprise Gabe” Sam said, he wants to surprise Gabe with flowers and a picnic. And he can’t wait for the Novak's family reactions to him talking after knowing that he was mute for the past 10 years.
~Tardis noises to an hour later~
“Sammy! Put your things in the moving truck and let's go!” Dean shouted from the bottom of the stairs. “I hear you Dean! I’m coming!” Sam shouted down the stairs. Their cousin Michael came out to help them pack for their trip back. “Hurry up Sammy!” Michael shouted. “You two are the most impatient people I know.” Sam said, setting his last box of things into the truck. “Alright, that’s everything. Let’s go home!” Dean said excitedly, he just saw his boyfriend an hour ago and he already missed his Cas. So they got on the road with Michael driving the moving truck with Dean and Sam following close behind in Dean’s Impala. They got there at about 10pm for Kansas; 8pm for Stanford. Sam was asleep, Dean suddenly stopped the car to wake him up. “What the fuck Dean!” Sam shouted. Heat of the moment was playing in the background; “RISE AND SHINE SAMMY, WE’RE HOME!” Dean shouted. Sam looked outside the window, he was home. He was back to being across the street from Gabe. “Holy shit-“ Sam said getting out of the car and immediately running inside. The house smelt like his childhood, and he ran upstairs, his room across the street from Gabe’s room. “Sammy! Come on! We need to unpack” Dean shouted. “Coming Dean!” Sam headed back downstairs so he can make his room his again.
~Tardis noises to the next morning~
Sam awoke to the smell of bacon. So he went downstairs to get himself some breakfast. Cas and Gabe were there. “Morning Dean-“ Sam said, not acknowledging the presence of the Novak’s. “Well hello to you too Samford” Gabe chuckled, Sam jerked his head to where the voice came from. He couldn’t believe his eyes, the boy he’s had a crush on for years, was in his house. “Gabe!” Sam smiled, picking up Gabe and swung him around in excitement. “Hi Sammy, I missed you too” Gabe smiled. His whiskey filled eyes lightened. Sam brought Gabe up to his room, just so he could do something he could never do in front of his brother. Sam closed the door to his room, and locked it. “I’ve really missed you Gabe” Sam said, nuzzling his face into Gabe’s neck. “Well I’m here with you now Sammy” Gabe messed up Sam’s hair. Sam looked up at Gabe, then at Gabe’s lips. “Can I kiss you Gabe-?” Sam asked.
“Of course you can Sammy, no need to ask” Gabe smiled. Sam smiled back before he kissed Gabe, god how he’s wanted this for years. Gabe kissed back, holding the back of Sam’s head, causing the kiss to get deeper. Sam moaned into Gabe’s mouth, putting his hands on Gabe’s waist. Gabe pulled away, letting Sam’s soft lips beg for his lips on Gabe’s. “Gabe please-“ Sam whined, wanting to taste Gabe again. “Beg Sammy, Beg for the kisses you want.” Sam whined, he really wanted the kisses; “Please Gabe pleaseeee.” He begged for the kisses. Gabe smiled, kissing Sam roughly and passionately. Sam kissed him back, setting Gabe on his bed. Gabe’s tongue pushed its way into Sam’s mouth, their tongues starting to dance with eachothers.
~CLIFFHANGER~
A/N;
Hi, this is the author making a note because he got writing block!!😁 Hopefully he gets to start on another one shot but for now, this’ll do❤️