Work Text:
Pinned
Johnathan woke slowly to the feeling of warmth and arousal. He sighed softly through his lips, enjoying the gentle pressure and gradually coming to recognize the feeling of a warm wet mouth gently sucking his cock. Smiling to himself he went to go run a hand through Nancy's hair to show he was awake.
Only, he couldn't move his hands.
Suddenly feeling much more awake, his eyes shot open and he looked up to see that his hands were tied to the headboard with a pair of scarves he definitely didn't own. Moving his eyes down he went to ask Nancy what the hell was happening only be met with the sight of…
"Steve!?" He nearly screeched, absolutely baffled to see Steve laying down on his stomach on the bed, mouth wrapped tightly around his cock
Steve looked up at him, not stopping his sucking, and while the sight certainly sent heat through his body, he was still panicking at the sight of Steve fucking Harrington sucking him off.
Sure they'd gotten closer after getting over the awkwardness of Nancy choosing Johnathan over Steve, but he didn't think they were his close, let alone that Steve might be into men. Johnathan wasn't even into men!
A touch to his cheek made him turn right, and he was met with the sight of a shirtless Nancy Wheeler laying beside him on the bed, smiling at him. That was a normal sight, that was usually a reassuring sight, but now he was just wondering why she was laying there at ease while her ex sucked him off.
"Hey Johnathan," she smiled at him, like this was a normal morning, "having fun?"
"Nancy! What the hell is happeninnnnnn" his question cut off as Steve suddenly decided to start sucking him harder, now bobbing his head on his dick, one hand coming up to roll his balls in his palm.
"We're just getting you ready sweetheart, you always come fast the first time, so Steve is getting you off now so you'll last for what's next" Nancy said as one of her hands moved down to tangle in Steve's hair. This prompted Steve to moan around him, causing his hips to buck, but instead of choking Steve just moaned louder, like he enjoyed Johnathan stuffing his throat with his cock.
"What!? Nance, what the hell! Why is this happening?" Nancy talked like this was something they had planned, like this was okay, like he wasn't in fact, feeling, and being, violated right now.
Click click click
"Oh Johnathan, calm down, we both know you want this. You're just too shy to ask, so we decided to take the initiative."
"Nance! You can't just do that! I don't want this actually! And you shouldn't have 'taken initiative', you should have talked to me." Tears were welling up in his eyes now as the full scope of the situation dawned on him. Tied down to his bed, legs spread, his friend still sucking him off as his girlfriend started to frown at him.
"Don't be so stubborn Johnathan. You wouldn't have agreed to this otherwise. That's why we had to act."
Johnathan opened his mouth to shoot back at her that he wouldn't have agreed, because he didn't want this, but instead his words caught in his throat as Steve chose that moment to pull up and off his cock, sucking hard the whole way up until he came off and Johnathan's dick slapped back against his stomach.
"Don't be shy Johnny, you're feeling good aren't you?" Steve asked, tilting his head so it rested against Johnathan's thigh, looking up at him from under his lashes. He really was unfairly pretty Johnathan thought to himself. Then shook that thought away, cause thinking someone was pretty was very different then agreeing to have sex with them. Which he didn't even do in this situation.
"That doesn't matter Steve! Just cause my body feels good doesn't mean you can just go ahead and have sex with me without my consent. That's called fucking rape!"
Click click click
"You're being ungrateful Johnathan," Nancy scolded, "Steve, keep going, I'm going to keep Johnathan occupied." And Nancy, beautiful Nancy, swung a leg over his face and that was when he realised she wasn't just not wearing a shirt, she wasn't wearing anything.
Steve chuckled from his place between Johnathan legs, "Oh now you're in for it baby, I suggest you not keep the lady waiting." Then he dipped his head back back and sucked Johnathan back into his mouth, only now he was moving up and down, taking his dick to the back of his throat and sucking and licking with every bob of his head.
Moaning out at the intense pleasure shooting through him, Nancy quickly took advantage of his open mouth and dropped her soaking pussy onto his tongue, grabbing his hair and holding him still as she rode her clit into his face.
Unable to do anything but take it, Johnathan couldn't even warn Steve about his impending orgasm. Could only moan louder and louder, muffled by Nancy on his face as she enjoyed the vibrations against her pussy, riding his face harder and harder as she reached her end just seconds before Johnathan cried up and spasmed, orgasm ripping through him and leaving his eyes rolling into the back of his head.
Distantly, he could feel Steve swallowing around him, drinking down all he had to give and a part of him found the thought extremely arousing.
When Nancy rolled off his face, he could finally take his first big gulp of air, only for it to whoosh out of him again as he felt a wet finger at his asshole. Looking down he saw Steve once again resting his head against his thigh, smiling as he gently massaged his hole, watching intently as he slowly fed him a finger.
"Steve, stop, stop, both of you, just stop!"
Click click click
Rolling back onto her side and cuddling into Johnathan, Nancy ran a finger along his chest, circling his nipple. "You know you don't want that Johnathan. Don't worry so much, Steve will be gentle, he was during our first time."
"I'll be good to you Johnathan, I'll stretch you out so good it won't even hurt when I slip inside." Steve punctuated the statement by biting down on his thigh and starting to suck a hickey into his skin.
"No, get off, let me up, let me go…" his pleading was cut off as Nancy stuck her fingers in his mouth and began pushing them back into his throat, causing him to gag.
"Fuck Nance, keep doing that, he tightens up when you do that." And yet, despite how he was apparently tensing up, Steve thought this was a good moment to add another finger, pushing in slowly but steadily, giving him a few moments to get used to it before he started spreading his fingers.
Now muffled, the only thing Johnathan could do was squirm, unable to move much with his arms tied above his head, Nancy's fingers in mouth pinning his head back and Steve's strong arms keeping his hips still as he added a third finger to his ass.
Moaning in distress, he tried shaking his head, trying to dislodge Nancy's fingers, feet scrambling uselessly beneath Steve's weight when suddenly he seized up, moans shifting in pitch to surprised pleasure.
"There we go!" Steve looked up at him with a huge smile on his face, like he did something good. "Isn't that better Johnathan? You know, if you had just stayed still, I would've found this," He punctuated this, with a few more hard thrust of his fingers, "a lot sooner. Feels so good doesn't it babe? You know I practised on myself first to make sure I could make it good for you." and if that statement didn't make Johnathan hot under the collar. Picturing Steve on his back, fingers in his ass trying to find a magical little spot that was making Johnathan slowly lose his mind to the pleasure coursing through his veins.
Nancy then removed her fingers from his mouth, dragging them down his chin to clean them from his spit.
"Isn't that so nice of him Johnathan? You should say 'thank you'."
Coming back himself, Johnathan suddenly remembered the situation he was in.
This wasn't a fun threesome he and his girlfriend planned. This was them tying him down and using his body. Refocusing his attention he tried to squirm away from Steve's fingers, but unable to go far he ended up just stimulating his sweet spot instead and letting out a loud moan.
"Like that baby? Need more? You're squirming so much." Chuckling between his thighs Steve leaned forward and gave a quick kiss to the base of his cock, now fully hard again and twitching with each thrust of Steve's fingers.
"Nnnn, no.." Panting heavily now, Johnathan turned his head, hiding his face in the crook of his arm.
"Steve, stop moving."
At Nancy's command Steve right away stopped the movement of his fingers and removed his mouth from where it had been sucking a new mark on Johnathan's thigh.
Gasping out, Johnathan's head whipped around to stare at Nancy. She met his gaze head on and gave him a stern look.
"You still haven't thanked him yet Johnathan. That's very rude, he went through all this work for you, and he's being very nice. You need to thank him or I'll make him stop."
Johnathan was torn, on one hand yes, he wanted this to end, he never wanted this in the first place. But on the other, it felt so good, his body was singing and he knew they would make him feel good. He was frozen with indecision, and he could feel tears gathering in his eyes.
Click click
Steve slowly removed his fingers and crawled up his body to lay against the front, the full body contact almost too much after the barest touches, but still so welcome and grounding. Nancy rolled close and pressed against his side, running a hand through his hair.
"Oh baby, are you overwhelmed? It's a lot huh, we've been taking care of you all morning and now you have to think. Poor baby." It should've been condescending, the way Steve was cooing at him, giving small kisses to his chest. Instead he just felt stupidly comforted, a few tears escaping and rolling down his cheeks.
"It's okay Johnathan, we're here for you. All we need is one word, just a 'thanks', and then we'll make you feel good." Nancy said, kissing the tears off his face.
Johnathan wanted to say no, to tell them to stop, wanted to keep his resolve strong. But with Steve pressed against him the way he was, his cock was pressed against his and he was getting some friction that just felt so good.
He tried to subtly move his hips to get some friction, but there was no hiding what he was doing with their position.
Steve pulled his hips up and away, shooting him a smile, "Now now Johnathan, don't be naughty. You know how to get more." now getting no relief Johnathan let out a small whine.
Glancing back and forth between the two beautiful people pressed against him, Johnathan gave in. He had no control here and as much as it scared and humiliated him, it also felt good.
"Thanks" he mumbled, almost inaudible, but it was enough.
Click click click
Grinning from ear to ear now, both of them pulled back and away from him, Steve returning to sit between his thighs and Nancy pulling up to straddle his hips, still denying his cock any touch.
"Good boy!" Nancy praised.
Blushing from her praise, Johnathan almost missed the feeling of something hard pressing up against his asshole.
"Steve wait, please don't do this!"
Click click click
"Don't be like that Johnathan, you thanked me, and this is your reward. Be good baby, I'm gonna make you feel so good." Hitching up his thighs and wrapping his legs around his waist, Steve started pushing into him.
Throwing his head back and moaning, Johnathan stared unseeing at his ceiling. The feeling was like nothing he ever felt before. Pressure and fullness so intense that he instinctively bared down, trying to force it out, but instead easing the way for Steve to bottom out in one long push.
"God Johnathan, you feel so good." Panting softly, Steve circled his hips lightly, stimulating them both while giving Johnathan time to adjust.
"Oh my god, oh my god!" Clenching his legs around Steve's waist Johnathan was slightly started when this caused Steve to moan out. Realising that he was squeezing Steve inside him Johnathan quickly forced himself to relax.
"Mmmmmm, good boy, just relax for me. We'll get to it in a minute. Nance?"
At his call of her name, Nancy then moved to straddle Johnathan, her back to him as she leaned in to kiss Steve.
Pulling back to rest their foreheads together, Nancy then reached below herself to grip Johnathan's cock.
"Nancy! No, no, I'll come Nancy, that's too much, I'll come!" Johnathan pleaded.
"No you won't babe, youll behave, otherwise you'll get punished." Not even sparing him a glance, Nancy then lowered herself down, sighing as she filled herself with his cock.
Johnathan tried to buck up, to bury himself in her heat, but Steve held his hips down, and he wished he didn't find that as hot as he did.
Hearing the sounds of lips smacking together Johnathan looked and saw Steve and Nancy softy making out. It made him feel lonely somehow, even though they were literally on top of, and attached to him. Without meaning to he let out a small whine, catching their attention.
Pulling apart Nancy glanced behind her. "Johnathan, okay?"
Click click
"Alone, why do I feel alone." Johnathan was spiralling a little, he couldn't help it and he didn't know why.
"Steve, help me out." Holding her hands to stabilize her, Nancy pulled up and off of his cock, and he whined again, louder this time.
"It's okay baby, just readjusting." Steve was quick to soothe him, circling his hips again to distract him as the feeling made him go a little boneless.
"Okay, here we go. Is this better, sweetheart?" Nancy had turned around and laid herself on top of him now. She brought her arms in to hold him, bracketing his head between them.
Click click click
"Good baby, aren't you getting better at telling us what you need. And to think, you were being so bratty before, acting like you didn't want this." As he spoke, Steve reached between Nancy and Johnathan's bodies, gripping his cock and guiding him to sink back inside of her.
Panting too much respond, Johnathan was more focused on not coming right away to really register the gentle tease. He couldn't remember a time when he didn't want this, didn't want these two beautiful people to play his body like an instrument, he was lost to the bliss of taking and being taken.
"I think he's ready honey, let's start." Lifting her hips as much as she could, Nancy started moving on his cock, keeping her while body pressed against his. He loved the grounding feeling her weight provided him, felt like he'd get lost without it.
He appreciated it even more as Steve started to move as well, the full length of his cock moving in and out of him, brushing his prostate on every pass, a beautiful counterpoint to Nancy's barely there movements which keep his own cock warm and wet.
He couldn't hold back anymore, his head tilted back to let out moans, growing louder by the minute as Steve picked up speed, adding more force to his thrusts. Nancy was almost still now, just grinding against him to get friction on her clit, clenching rhythmically around him as she chased her pleasure. He tried to move, to add to the pleasure, but pinned and impaled as he was, his hips were just barely able to twitch back and forth. He was just here for the ride, here to be used, to be a cock to fill Nancy and a hole for Steve to sink into. He had no say in his pleasure, just had to take what was given, and it was pure luck that these people were givers, happy to take him along the waves of pleasure.
Johnathan didn't know how long they stayed like that, writhing together, before he felt himself start to approach the edge. He tried to warm them, but his tongue was thick in his mouth, useless, as he tried to speak. Thankfully, though, they seemed to understand.
"Just a little more Johnathan, just hold on, I'm so close, be good for me and hold on just a little longer." Clenching tighter and tighter around him, Nancy sat up, and with the new angle she was really able to grind forward. She grabbed handfuls of his chest, using the grip to bounce herself slightly, chasing her end as her moaning picked up.
Behind her, Steve reached up with one hand, grabbing at her breasts and moving back and forth, making sure each nipple got some attention, pinching and rubbing at them in alternating patterns. From over her shoulder Steve stared down at Johnathan, hearted gaze meeting his as he licked and sucked at Nancy's neck from behind.
Seizing up on his cock, Nancy shuddered through her orgasm, crying out and pussy gripping him like a vice, liquid gushed out of her and Johnathan couldn't stop himself from following her right over the edge. His cries joined hers as the rush gave him the strength to push up into her, cumming in hot spurts as he pushed himself into as far as he could and grinding his cum into her as deep as he could.
They stilled in the aftermath, panting, and after a few moments she slipped off of him. Some of him cum leaked out of her, dripping down her thighs and making a mess. Johnathan wanted to lick it up, to chase the taste of himself back into her, eat it out of her and see what they tasted like mixed together. But as she tipped over and fell onto the bed, Johnathan was reminded that this wasn't over yet.
Steve gave a hard thrust, the sound of skin slapping on skin bringing Johnathan back to the moment. "Did you forget about me baby? We aren't done yet. I'm gonna come in this tight ass and I want you to scream for me." Steve moved to hover over him now, hands coming up to grip Johnathan's shoulders.
Click click click
Another hard thrust and Johnathan cried out as his nerves lit up, overstimulated, and yet he could feel his cock twitch and push out a little more cum. It was too much, it was overwhelming, he felt tears run down his face and hear himself screaming now, calling out for Steve to stop, overstimulated, but Steve kept going.
Click click click click click
Steve was hammering at him now, chasing his own end, he basically was just using Johnathan as a fleshlight, even as he tightened up and made it hard for Steve to enter him, Steve just put more force behind his thrusts. Groaning low in his throat, he leaned his full body weight on Jonathan and thrust his hips, rhythm turning jerky and losing his pace as he approached his end. But what finally tipped him over the edge was Nancy, she sat up and reached behind him, and whatever she did behind his body has Steve crying out, had him shoot down and sink his teeth into Johnathan's shoulder and he muffled his own scream, thrusting forward one more time before stilling, as deep inside of Johnathan as he could get and cumming in pulses that Johnathan could feel as hot cum filled him up. And Johnathan felt himself come again, no mess this time, just wracking shudders causing him to convulse beneath Steve.
When they were done, both of them collapsed, Johnathan on the bed and Steve on top of him. Panting into each other's skin they lay there for a few moments trying to catch their breath.
Suddenly Johnathan felt one of his arms hit the bed.
"Sorry Johnathan, lost my grip." Nancy smiled above him, hair dishevelled and beautiful.
She continued on to his other arm, not expecting a reply since he was still trying to come back to his body. Gently, this time, she placed his arm down and opened his fingers to remove the clicker still grasped there. After placing it on the bedside table, she massaged his hands, paying special attention to the indents left in his palm from how tightly he'd been gripping it.
"You good baby?" Steve asked, finally dragging his face out from where it'd been buried in the side of his neck. "Got a bit click happy there at the end." Even though it was said like a joke, Johnathan could see the uncertainty hiding in his eyes.
Johnathan just laughed, "Yeah, couldn't stop honestly, my hand was just going." Steve subtly relaxed at that, joining in his laughter.
The motion made them moan, however, as they were still attached. Nancy just laughed at them.
"Fuck, hold on baby." Steve didn't even need to go far, just pulled his hips up, and his soft cock slipped out.
He then sat up and looked at where they'd just been joined, watching his cum flow out of Johnathan.
Feeling embarrassed, Johnathan closed his legs, giving Steve a mock glare. Steve just gave him a satisfied grin, giving his leg a light slap as he moved off the bed.
"Be right back lovies." Tossing a wink over his shoulder, Steve pulled on his boxers and left the room.
Nancy slid down the bed, coming to rest beside Johnathan and resting her head and hand on his chest.
"Are you okay Johnathan?"
"Yeah, I'm alright." He smiled at her, bringing his hand down to link their fingers together.
"Was it everything you wanted?"
"Yeah, it was better than I could've hoped for. I think I really needed this." God knows the past year had been stressful. It was like he just couldn't relax, waiting for something more to happen. When Nancy and Steve had suggested forcing him to relax, to take him out of his own head, Johnathan couldn't agree fast enough.
"Uhh, hey guys," Walking back into the room, wet washcloth in hand, Steve had a sheepish look on his face. "So Will came back early…"
"....."
"......"
The silence in the room was heavy for a moment, but all it took was making eye contact with each other, for all of them to just burst out laughing.
Omake * Bonus Scene
Waking to the bathroom, Steve hummed lightly to himself as he ran a hand towel under warm water. The scene had gone really well, Johnathan looked relaxed for the first time in weeks, all fucked out and glowing in satisfaction, Nancy as well took to taking the lead really well. He was excited to see what else she could do now that they'd figured themselves out.
Giving himself a quick wipe down, Steve rinsed off the cloth before moving to exit the bathroom.
Only to be met with a shotgun aimed at his face.
"What the fuck!?" Stumbling back, Steve looked beyond the barrel to see Will, a hard look in his eyes. "What the fuck Byers?"
"What did you do to my brother?" Voice harder than he'd ever heard before, even when he was possessed, Will stared him down.
"Uhhhh, Will, I don't think you wanna know."
"I came home early, I heard him telling you to stop, what did you do to him?"
"Will, I'm sorry you had to find out this way, but I really don't think you want the details of your brother's kinky sex life."
Will just stared at him, blank faced as he tried and failed to process that sentence. Finally it seemed to hit him and, realising just what he'd come upon, Will's mouth dropped, and thankfully, so did his arms, bringing the shotgun to point at the ground.
Now staring at each other awkwardly, Steve took control of the situation. "So, maybe you can talk to him about that later, but right now I need to go help them clean up."
"Them!?" Somehow Will managed to look even more distressed, and Steve did not want to even guess what was going on in his head.
"Nancy and Johnathan." He clarified.
".......okay?" Poor Will, he looked like his mind was stalling.
"Okay, I'm gonna go now baby Byers. Don't tell your mom okay?"
".....sure." Will whispered, and with that he backed out of the bathroom and took off to his room, shutting the door gently.
Now free, Steve moved quickly back to Johnathan's room. He was not looking forward to breaking the news to the others.