Work Text:
Amy grinned mischievously, leaning in slightly. "Never have I ever honked if I liked something."
Sheldon grimaced and didn’t drink. Naturally, he would never do something so impulsive. The very thought made his skin crawl with discomfort. He pondered for a moment, crafting his next question.
“Never have I ever thrown, caught, or touched a Frisbee,” he announced with an air of confidence.
Amy lifted her glass to her lips, then paused, shaking her head with a playful smile. She didn't play Frisbee, of course! Sheldon chuckled along with her, surprised to find this silly game unexpectedly entertaining.
Amy shot back, “Never have I ever put salt on my food without trying it first.”
Sheldon raised his free hand in a mock show of dignity.
He took a moment to think, “Oh, I’ve got one. Never have I ever...” He paused for effect, watching Amy’s anticipation grow. “...pushed all the buttons in an elevator.”
To his surprise, Amy raised her glass slowly, locking eyes with him as she took a small sip of red wine.
Sheldon’s eyes widened in shock, his lips forming a perfect ‘O’. Scandalous, he thought, a mixture of disbelief and fascination flashing across his face.
Amy placed her glass on the coffee table, smiling coyly. “Well, we all have a past.”
Still grinning in disbelief, Sheldon leaned forward, his curiosity piqued. “Amy, you naughty girl. When did this happen?”
“Oh, back in grad school. There was this fancy building, and the elevator was so sleek, I couldn’t resist.”
“Amy!” he exclaimed in mock horror. “That’s the most rebellious thing I’ve ever heard you do... aside from that one time you didn’t sanitize your hands after holding a door handle,” he added dryly.
“Yeah,” she laughed. “I was feeling pretty rebellious that day. Also, a bit annoyed because the guys in my lab made fun of my nose again, saying it looked like the mouse we were dissecting.”
Sheldon studied her face thoughtfully, considering how anyone could have mocked her features. Her nose wasn’t mouse-like at all. Well, maybe... just a little like a parrot's, but definitely not a mouse. Either way, it was uniquely Amy, and he loved every part of her.
“Well, I think I’ve won this round,” Sheldon said, placing his drink down with an air of triumph.
Amy smirked. “Are we playing some more? Penny and Leonard are still in the other room.”
“They’re probably discussing how to draft their divorce papers so Penny can get all of Leonard’s money to pay off her debt,” Sheldon quipped.
“Sheldon, be nice! You've already caused them enough trouble today.”
“What? I was just playing the game. It would’ve come out eventually. Leonard is a terrible liar. Just two days ago, he told me he hated changing the water cooler filter, yet I know for a fact he enjoys doing it every week.”
Amy raised an eyebrow. “How do you know that wasn’t a lie?”
“Why would he keep doing it every week if he didn’t like it, Amy? Think logically.”
She chuckled. “You’re right.”
“I’m always right.”
“Sure, Mr. Always Right,” Amy teased. “Let’s play one more round. Let’s see if you can stay unbeaten.”
Sheldon looked skeptical. “Really, Amy? I’ve already exceeded my alcohol quota for the day.”
“You took two sips, Sheldon.”
“And that’s one sip too many.”
“Okay, fine.” Amy's smirk deepened, a mischievous glint dancing in her eyes. “We don’t have to drink. Let’s change the rules a little.”
“And how do you propose we do that?” Sheldon asked, intrigued.
Amy glanced around the room thoughtfully, her lips curving into a mischievous smile. “Instead of taking a drink, if you’ve done something, you have to kiss the other person... on the lips.”
Sheldon blinked, considering the proposal. It was a reasonable compromise—certainly better than alcohol. “Interesting… You really are a naughty girl, Amy Farrah Fowler.”
Amy’s grin widened as she leaned in a little closer. “So, are you in?”
Sheldon cleared his throat. “Okay, but—” he raised a finger, “no funny business. Behave yourself. Penny and Leonard are just in the other room, and who knows what wild animal might be lurking outside this cabin, ready to pounce. I need to remain alert.”
“You are so dramatic,” Amy laughed, shaking her head.
“It’s called being prepared,” Sheldon corrected, sitting up straighter.
“Okay, just a peck.”
He narrowed his eyes suspiciously but eventually nodded. “Very well. Let’s proceed.”
Amy clapped her hands excitedly. “Okay, I’ll start!”
Sheldon settled back on the sofa as Amy shifted to face him. She tapped her chin thoughtfully, then began, “Never have I ever... lied about my age.”
Neither moved.
Sheldon went next, “Never have I ever eaten all the marshmallows out of a cereal box and left the healthy bits.”
Amy rolled her eyes. “I don’t do that. You do.”
“Hey, I’m asking the questions here.”
Amy smirked. “Alright, never have I ever... switched places with a twin.”
Sheldon scoffed. “Nice try, Amy. There’s no universe where I would willingly switch places with my sister.”
“Worth a shot.” She shrugged.
Sheldon raised his eyebrow. “Never have I ever been attacked by a wild animal.”
Amy shook her head with a giggle.
“Didn’t your cigarette-addicted monkey try to chew off your eyebrows?”
“Hey, Ricky was a friend! He’s not a wild animal,” Amy retorted.
“Well say what you will, the longer we stay in this cabin, the higher the chances of getting attacked by a raging capuchin monkey,” Sheldon muttered.
Amy rolled her eyes again. “Relax. We’re fine. Okay, never have I ever... cried when a fictional character died.”
Sheldon hesitated before nodding slowly. “I suppose I have.”
“Spock?” Amy guessed.
“Ironic, isn’t it?” Sheldon mused. “He’s supposed to be this emotionless figure I admired, yet when he died in The Wrath of Khan, I couldn’t help but shed a tear. Mr. Spock wouldn’t have been proud.”
“I think it’s touching,” Amy said softly.
Sheldon paused, gazing at her with a small, appreciative smile. He leaned in and placed a gentle kiss on her lips, lingering for a moment before pulling back.
Amy grinned. “Never have I ever peed in the shower.”
Sheldon recoiled in disgust. “That’s vile! I certainly hope you haven’t.”
“Ew, of course not!”
“Good.” Sheldon gave a satisfied nod, pausing as his gaze flicked briefly to her lips. A small glint of mischief in his eyes as he shifted slightly closer to her. He hesitated just long enough to make her wonder before continuing, his lips curling into a subtle smirk.
“Never have I ever kissed someone in a cabin.”
Amy arched an eyebrow, her lips curving into a knowing smile. Without hesitation, she leaned forward and pressed a soft kiss to his lips.
Pulling back, Amy asked “Never have I ever met someone on an online dating app set up by my two friends.”
Sheldon laughed. “That’s specific.”
“I’m here to win,” Amy quipped as Sheldon leaned in for a quick peck.
They continued the back-and-forth, exchanging playful accusations and kisses, each one growing slightly longer, more deliberate. Their game began to melt into something deeper, their proximity making it harder to focus on the questions.
Sheldon’s voice softened as he murmured, “Never have I ever... loved someone so much I couldn’t bear to be apart.”
Amy’s eyes sparkled. “Never have I ever... wanted to kiss someone as much as I do right now.”
Sheldon’s gaze drifted to her lips, his heartbeat quickening. Slowly, they both leaned in, their breaths mingling. Their lips met in a tender, passionate kiss—soft at first, but deepening as Sheldon's hand cupped Amy’s face, pulling her closer. Time seemed to slow, the world outside the cabin disappearing as they sank into the moment, savoring the connection.
When she finally pulled away, breathless and amused, she tilted her head, her fingers gently caressing his chest over the fabric of his shirt. “What happened to ‘no funny business,’ huh?”
Sheldon raised an eyebrow, completely nonchalant. “I reconsidered the parameters of the game. This is... much better.” He paused, his voice softening as he added, “I think we both won.”
Amy smiled, her lips brushing his once more, her voice low and warm. “I think so too.”
The End