Only a Lad
BUFFY: You're like a serial killer in prison.
SPIKE: Women marry 'em all the time!
Many thanks to thefourthvine for telling me that the third guy was obviously Loki. Couldn't have done it without you!
Gratitude is also due to esteefee, oyceter, and absolutedestiny for cheerleading, and to P. for figuring out what to do with that final shot.
Posted unbetaed and without shame.