Cory was going to kill Amanda. Okay, so he had lost the bet. But why… oh why had he agreed that the loser would do whatever the winner asked them to, except for giving up their head? Oh yes… he hadn't thought he would lose.
However, Cory didn't understand what he had ever done to Amanda to deserve this. Maybe she just wanted to have a laugh at his expense. That had to be it.
Why else would she have forced him to pretend he was a pastor in an isolated Alaskan town?