"Maybe this was faith."
"Clearly faith isn't on our side."
It never ever was they both thought bitterly.
Or the AU where Penelope is a vampire and accidentally turns Josie into a heretic that no one asked for.
A hizzie/posie high school au that I'm pretty sure has already been done for:
Hope and Lizzie have always had a petty rivalry for since the 6th grade. At the end of Junior year Lizzie crossed a line. And Hope was prepared to hate her for it. But after summer Lizzie isn't quite like herself and Hope seems like the only person that wants to find out why.
Lizzie was diagnosed with bipolar disorder over the summer and now has to start senior year, adjusting to meds and just feeling out of place.
Posie the sure bet couple broke up over the summer will they find their way back to eachother?
it was bad, then it got messy and now it's both