19 Works in Fingers in My Mouth Friday (Supernatural)

Listing Works

  1. Tags
    Summary

    "Did you—did you wipe my fucking memories?"

    Cas tilts his head, little worry lines scrunching between his furrowed brows.

    "Of course I did, Dean."

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    4,384
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    31
    Kudos:
    108
    Bookmarks:
    19
    Hits:
    828
  2. Tags
    Summary

    Dean Winchester, better known as the “Lonesome Rider” throughout the Wild West, spends his days galavanting from town to town, drinking, dancing, and flirting his way into people’s beds. He’s got no responsibilities and no direction in life; it’s just him, his beloved horse, Baby, and the open road. And that’s just the way Dean likes it𑁋or so he tells himself.

    That is, until the day Sam falls deathly ill. When nothing is able to cure him, Dean makes a desperate deal to save Sam’s life that puts his own on the line. Enter Castiel Novak, a small town preacher in possession of the Colt, a gun rumored to be able to kill just about anything as well as the one thing that could save Dean’s life. When the gun is stolen by a gang of infamous outlaws, Dean and Castiel must travel across the West together to get it back, though what they discover between themselves along the way may turn out to be more powerful than the Colt itself.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    67,344
    Chapters:
    11/11
    Collections:
    1
    Comments:
    18
    Kudos:
    65
    Bookmarks:
    49
    Hits:
    1361
  3. Tags
    Summary

    Castiel’s fading grace is making the separation between angel and vessel less clear, and their wings are having a hard time staying on the correct plane.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    3,761
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    1
    Kudos:
    37
    Bookmarks:
    3
    Hits:
    556
  4. Tags
    Summary

    Cas was resurrected. Dean told Cas that he loves him, that he can have everything he wanted, but Cas has to stay with him. Cas promised that he would. The thing is, he didn’t realize how literal Dean was being.

    Now, Cas works on rebuilding Heaven with the angels, while he builds a new life with Dean. Neither of those things are as easy as Cas would have liked.

    *

    “Angels have been interfering for too long,” Jack insists. “Humanity deserves some peace, and I intend to give it to them.”

    “Then why did Cas go back?” Anna demands.

    “That doesn’t matter,” Cas says, willing Anna to just let it go.

    “Yes it does!” she argues instead.

    “And Heaven deserves some peace too!” Jack continues, raising his voice. “That won’t happen if we’re getting into conflicts on Earth.”

    “Then why does Cas get to go back and I don’t?”

    “That’s different,” Jack says. Cas cringes.

    “Why, because it’s the Winchesters?” Anna asks. “The old God is dead, why are they still the centre of the universe?”

    “Because it’s Dean,” Cas says.

    “And?!”

    “And I love him!”

    "It's still not fair. You can't set up rules and exceptions and call Heaven free."

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    71,770
    Chapters:
    7/8
    Comments:
    176
    Kudos:
    252
    Bookmarks:
    52
    Hits:
    5960
  5. Tags
    Summary

    "You’re the only angel I can trust with this request.” He didn’t completely trust her, either. But they’d never tried to kill one another, which was at least something. “I know I’ve been focused on Jack’s soul today. But I was hoping...I’d like you to check if I have a soul.”

    What happens when Cas wakes up in the Empty a second time, and rescues his own damn self?

    At first, it seems like the happy ending Dean thought he’d lost his chance to ever know. But as the two set out on a celebratory road trip and begin enjoying their new life together, there’s a darkness clinging to Cas that refuses to completely let go. They may need to make an altogether different kind of journey in order to put the past fully behind them.

    And meanwhile, where is Jack, anyway?

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    117,878
    Chapters:
    26/26
    Collections:
    2
    Comments:
    74
    Kudos:
    97
    Bookmarks:
    56
    Hits:
    2700
  6. Tags
    Summary

    Cas takes Dean's temperature. Very, very thoroughly.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    4,269
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    17
    Kudos:
    154
    Bookmarks:
    11
    Hits:
    1228
  7. Tags
    Summary

    “Most household chemicals are much more obvious with their intentions. Drain cleaners, for instance, corrode the inner lining of the oesophagus on the way down first, then the gastric lining, then if the victim is lucky, the oesophagus again, on reflux. Otherwise it just keeps going, eating you from the inside out. Your lungs fill with water, the flesh collapses in on itself. You’re dead within the hour."

    There’s different kinds of violence in this world, see: of fists & pills & words & belts & everything in between. Cas has never really been good at any kind but the first, & Dean would like to think that it’s the mark that’s teaching him this one now. But he knows it was probably him.

    MoC Cas before he makes it to the grave.

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    5,709
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Kudos:
    29
    Bookmarks:
    6
    Hits:
    217
  8. Tags
    Summary

    “But, Cas, I-”

    “SHH!” Cas said, and then he reached up and pressed his index finger to Dean’s mouth.

    Dean shut up.

    Cas just glared at him for a moment, his fingertip pressed to Dean’s lips, and Dean’s brain immediately stopped functioning. Cas had his finger. On Dean’s mouth. His finger.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    10,414
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    19
    Kudos:
    170
    Bookmarks:
    22
    Hits:
    1484
  9. Tags
    Summary

    Dean gets hit by a very specific potion that only Castiel can help him with.

    And, boy, does he help.

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    6,662
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    16
    Kudos:
    212
    Bookmarks:
    30
    Hits:
    3683
  10. Tags
    Summary

    Castiel is alive. He's back from the Empty, and he knows Dean loves him too. He had been so sure that Dean was going to kiss him.

    He couldn't. Castiel's deal is still in effect. If Dean kisses him, or says anything back, he will die again.

    Jack seems to think that Castiel will get out of the deal. Castiel knows better. His actions have consequences. To himself, and to Dean, who wants him too and still can't have him.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    25,141
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    34
    Kudos:
    240
    Bookmarks:
    56
    Hits:
    2546
  11. Tags
    Summary

    Castiel discovers that if he gives Dean his Grace, it can help mitigate the effects of the Mark of Cain. They are both unbearably h0rny about it.

    Consumehimnatural

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    5,287
    Chapters:
    3/?
    Comments:
    1
    Kudos:
    55
    Bookmarks:
    4
    Hits:
    780
  12. Tags
    Summary

    Cas borrows a pair of Dean's jorts to help him wash the car. Dean immediately gets sidetracked.

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    793
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    15
    Kudos:
    259
    Bookmarks:
    21
    Hits:
    2120
  13. Tags
    Summary

    Castiel doesn’t know how he got from the Empty to the floor of a barn. The last thing he remembers is saying his confession before falling with Dean onto the hay. And Dean has been different since his rescue, has thrown out all boundaries he’d ever said were customary. Humans always manage to surprise Castiel. Dean surprises him most of all.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    20,428
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Collections:
    2
    Comments:
    72
    Kudos:
    961
    Bookmarks:
    253
    Hits:
    7279
  14. Tags
    Summary

    What if Cas' eventual confession had come in season 13, when Cas comes back from the Empty? Would Dean still be an inarticulate ball of insecurity that flees from his own happiness? Well, yes. But maybe they would have time to work on it.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    43,018
    Chapters:
    6/6
    Comments:
    32
    Kudos:
    246
    Bookmarks:
    56
    Hits:
    5128
  15. Tags
    Summary

    "My wings inspired you," Cas says, smug at the thought.

    "Yeah, I'm feelin' pretty fuckin' inspired right now, man."

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    5,101
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    37
    Kudos:
    402
    Bookmarks:
    44
    Hits:
    2929
  16. Tags
    Summary

    "Listen, man, It's not like, a thing... It's just, well, you have nice hands, and you kinda marked me... with your very large hand." Dean still wanted to disappear, but Cas didn't seem too bothered.

    - alternatively -

    It's been years since Dean got laid, cut him some slack

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    3,545
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    14
    Kudos:
    248
    Bookmarks:
    22
    Hits:
    2828
  17. Tags
    Summary

    Dean knows exactly why he’d pulled Cas out of the Empty. It’s not charity. It’s selfishness. He’d made Cas lose his paradise, the version of life the Empty had created for him with his mirage of Dean, just because Dean was too scared to be alone. Dean had promised Cas that he’d pretend for him. He’d said he’d do whatever Cas needed to be as happy here as he’d been in the Empty’s reality. But Dean doesn’t even know how to be the person Cas thinks he is.

    Either Cas is lying, or his standards are impossibly low. Cas apparently thought it’d be enough for him just to be near Dean. But that’s not what love should be. It should want something back. Dean’s own feelings are irrelevant. He wants Cas, wants to be someone who deserves him. He can’t have him. He can’t construct a monologue about his reasons for loving Cas like Cas had done for him. He’s pretty sure that holding Cas’s hand would make him combust, after so long subsisting on scraps of shoulder-pats and Cas only touching him to heal him.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    26,713
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    44
    Kudos:
    504
    Bookmarks:
    138
    Hits:
    4410
  18. Tags
    Summary

    “Hey,” Dean says. He taps Cas on the shoulder. “Hold up your hand.”

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    3,818
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    26
    Kudos:
    392
    Bookmarks:
    60
    Hits:
    3681
  19. Tags
    Summary

    “What? Does watching me snore get your rocks off or something?”

    Dean’s tone borders on joking, but the words burn uncomfortably in Castiel’s ears. He can feel where the whole line of his body tenses. He needs to leave, needs to escape and wrap all of his rotten fantasies up in a tight little box and throw them away where they will never see the light of day again. Castiel swallows, jolts as his eyes dart around and refuse to meet Dean’s.

    “Wait.” Dean sounds disbelieving. Castiel wants to disappear. “Wait, seriously, Cas?”

    or the one where cas doesn't really understand how human kinks work or why he finds dean sleeping so hot, and dean is just excited to do something that cas wants

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    13,506
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    142
    Kudos:
    990
    Bookmarks:
    244
    Hits:
    10190

Filters

Filter results:
Submit

Include

?
Include Ratings
Include Warnings
Include Categories
Include Fandoms
Include Characters
Include Relationships
Include Additional Tags

Exclude

?
Exclude Ratings
Exclude Warnings
Exclude Categories
Exclude Fandoms
Exclude Characters
Exclude Relationships
Exclude Additional Tags

More Options

Crossovers
Completion Status
Word Count
Date Updated
Submit