The Witch Is Dead
In 1988, three witches in Montana are growing a monster in their garden, and Sam is holiday snack. When Dean and John show up to get him, one witch is killed, and Dean gets a love curse that he keeps secret. As teenagers, Sam and Dean are living in a dying industrial town in Pennsylvania, where they come across a crooked old creature that takes an unusual interest in Dean. As adults, Sam and Dean return to Montana for a hunt and run into the two surviving witches who have been unsuccessfully trying to grow their monster. Dean, still carrying the love spell from the dead witch, is looking like perfect plant feed.
- Part 1 of The Witch Is Dead
This is a timestamp to "The Witch Is Dead", in which they are in San Juan, PR, there is a hooker and a bad moment of eye contact, and Dean wonders if the love spell has finally caught up with him. Takes place between chapters 2 and 3.
- Part 2 of The Witch Is Dead
With a job in San Juan, PR completed, Sam and Dean head to a wild beach, to burn a dead monster and drink tequila in an abandoned restaurant.
- Part 3 of The Witch Is Dead