Comment on Upcoming changes to kudos

  1. This doesn't feature in stats, which you can sort by to rank fics.

    Comment Actions
    1. purple flowers

      Au contraire, you can sort by comments as easily as you can by kudos. Another option is to hit the bookmark button; people can sort by that stat, too, and also maybe find the fic from seeing your bookmark.

      Comment Actions
      1. Still doesn't feature in the kudos stats which most people seem to use to check for well-regarded fics. You can artificially inflate comments - intentionally or otherwise.

        Comment Actions
        1. purple flowers

          The point being that not being able to artificially inflate kudos is a good thing, right?

          Comment Actions
          1. Obviously.

            I respond with thanks for each comment I receive - this would suggest double the number of comments. Courtesy and gratitude (or back and forth discussion), therefore, results in suggestion of double the comments actually received.

            Last Edited Thu 12 Mar 2020 12:39PM EDT

            Comment Actions
            1. purple flowers

              I’m glad we’re in agreement! This is a great bugfix AO3 is implementing to make the kudos statistic more fair for everyone.

              Comment Actions
        2. made by lostgirl  (lostgirlslair on LJ)

          "Most" people? Some people.

          A lot of kudos means *nothing*--utter garbage gets a lot of kudos. There are many people who kudos every single fic they read, so that tells you ZERO about fic quality.

          I mean, if all you want is "this fic hits all the currently trendy tropes" then I guess.

          Comment Actions
          1. Honestly, friend, thank you for saying this. <3

            Comment Actions
    2. It does, you can also sort by amount of comments, or bookmarks, which is another way to give love to authors. I'm sorry, but this whole thing is a non-issue.

      Comment Actions
      1. It might be in your opinion.

        Comment Actions
        1. It's a non-issue in the opinion of anyone who deserves to be taken seriously on the issue.

          Comment Actions
          1. What a wise and helpful contribution by someone without the nerve to log in to say it!

            Comment Actions
            1. made by lostgirl  (lostgirlslair on LJ)

              I'm logged in, and I'll agree with them!

              Comment Actions
      2. I completely agree! I always sort by bookmarks when searching; not to cheapen kudos, they're great, but bookmarking means you want to remember that story, you want to come back to that story. Kind of like buying a book you've already read from the library. And really, while kudos and bookmarks show love, you could theoritically just write "wtf man" in a comment :D

        Comment Actions
        1. blooming evening primrose

          "wtf man" without anything else can be perceived as negative, so this is maybe not the best example ;)

          But I completely agree with the rest of cour comment! :)

          Last Edited Sun 15 Mar 2020 05:03AM EDT

          Comment Actions
          1. yeah, i figured, it was actually intended to show that -- like, you don't kudo or bookmark works you don't like, but technically you could leave a comment on something you don't like, though i'm not sure that's a productive use of anyone's time, except if the author specifically asked for criticism (and i'm assuming most authors would delete rude ones anyway.) and there's some lovely discussion going on in the comments sometimes, though i'm not sure how replies are counted :D so it's maybe not the most reliable way of sorting works. if you only want to read. it might come in handy if someone wanted to measure how active each fandom is, like, hits to comments (comments to hits?) ratio :D

            Last Edited Sun 15 Mar 2020 03:59PM EDT

            Comment Actions
            1. blooming evening primrose

              Ah, I misunderstood! I read your first comment in the same vain as all the "when you want to leave more kudos you could just write a comment with 'kudos'/'I like this!' etc. Now, when I re-read it, I realized that wasn't what you meant :D

              And I actually have seen "wtf man" comments...

              Comment Actions
        2. Glad to see I'm not the only one! I figure also that since bookmarking takes more effort in comparison to kudos, the more people putting in that effort then the more that they like it.

          Comment Actions