1 Work by donutsandcoffee in How I Met Your Mother
For those who have heard the story, mind you, without any background knowledge whatsoever—they may have concluded that it is actually a short story, the one that starts when the yellow umbrella comes into the picture.
They are wrong.
(Luke Mosby knows everyone in Dad's stories--Uncle Marshall, Aunt Robin, even Wendy the Waitress--but not the way his Dad knows them. Alternate Interpretation.)